Can We All Finally Agree Donovan Needs To Burn In Hell (even you phreak)

[MDS]

why the farg would baltimore want mcnabb...flacco is better than mcnabb right now...forget the fact hes young

you keep forgetting only eagles fans know the real 5. everyone else thinks hes a legend. teams might be dumb to enough to pull the trigger not knowing what they are getting. 

[rjs246]

No.

[MDS]

the eagles signed mike vick. you have no idea what any of those teams are thinking. its not out of the realm of possibility that some team like bmore says farg it lets go for it and tries to get 5 for the right price.

im not suggesting its going to happen, just saying considering what that article said perhaps the ravens fit into that category

[General_Failure]

My sources say New Orleans and Indy are dark horses.

My source says New England, and he can beat up your source.

[rjs246]

Is it possible to beat up fictional characters?

[General_Failure]

I don't see why not.

[rjs246]

Good, then we're all on the same page here.

[General_Failure]

Except our sources, who are now shirtless and grappling.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Is it possible to beat up fictional characters?

I assumed the source was your dog's eye boogers.  You can read them like tea leaves.

[Rome]

I swear to God I want him traded for no other reason than so when I log on here I won't see this thread at the top of the queue anymore.

[Sgt PSN]

ok

dc - new gm and coach, idiot owner, maybe they dont think campbell can get it done and have a 4-5 year plan to win and figure mcnabb is the qb to do it
cinci- epic fail from palmer in the playoffs, silly management and ownership that might be willing to do that
jets- sb caliber defense, sanchez not good enough yet, mcnabb comes in and tutors him and they win
kc- cassel sucks but then again so does that team
bmore- sb caliber team but mediocre qb. mcnabb familiar with harbaugh.

out of all of those dc and bmore make the most sense. obviously bmore would be a more likely spot. its not like joe flacco is lighting up the world.

after posting this, you really have no leg to stand on when it comes to insulting reese, cole, munson etc. 

dc - as already stated, the eagles are not trading mcnabb to a division rival.
cinci - if palmer is a playoff failure, then replacing him with mcnabb would be like using the hindenburg to bring the titanic survivors to safety. 
jets - you don't start a rookie qb for the entire season, go to the conf champ game with him and then bench him. 
kc - so horrible right now, especially at o-line, it's hard to tell what type of qb cassell is.  regardless, they invested a lot in him and aren't going to replace him after 1 season. 
bal - this might be the dumbest one of all. 

[Don Ho]

cinci - if palmer is a playoff failure, then replacing him with mcnabb would be like using the hindenburg to bring the titanic survivors to safety. 

[MDS]

ok

dc - new gm and coach, idiot owner, maybe they dont think campbell can get it done and have a 4-5 year plan to win and figure mcnabb is the qb to do it
cinci- epic fail from palmer in the playoffs, silly management and ownership that might be willing to do that
jets- sb caliber defense, sanchez not good enough yet, mcnabb comes in and tutors him and they win
kc- cassel sucks but then again so does that team
bmore- sb caliber team but mediocre qb. mcnabb familiar with harbaugh.

out of all of those dc and bmore make the most sense. obviously bmore would be a more likely spot. its not like joe flacco is lighting up the world.

after posting this, you really have no leg to stand on when it comes to insulting reese, cole, munson etc. 

dc - as already stated, the eagles are not trading mcnabb to a division rival.
cinci - if palmer is a playoff failure, then replacing him with mcnabb would be like using the hindenburg to bring the titanic survivors to safety. 
jets - you don't start a rookie qb for the entire season, go to the conf champ game with him and then bench him. 
kc - so horrible right now, especially at o-line, it's hard to tell what type of qb cassell is.  regardless, they invested a lot in him and aren't going to replace him after 1 season. 
bal - this might be the dumbest one of all. 

i keep forgetting how farging smart everyone is

these are minuscule, very unlikely trade partners for 5. the article said a couple teams are into him but are leaving their teams out. so here are some far fetched ideas as to who those teams might be. perhaps kc is way too far fetched, ill give you that.

the fact is the eagles signed mike vick. the phillies traded roy halladay for cliff lee. the pats traded drew bledsoe to the bills. we have no idea what these teams are taking about or what will happen. so we speculate and bla bla bla comment when stuff goes down. 

[Don Ho]

But would the Niners be willing to part with that hand in favor of a proven commodity like Donovan McNabb?

With the landscape of the NFC West changing - Kurt Warner and Anquan Boldin out in Arizona; a new regime under Pete Carroll in Seattle and a rebuilding Rams team in St. Louis - the belief is that the division is there for the taking. San Francisco has playmakers in receiver Michael Crabtree, tight end Vernon Davis and running back Frank Gore. The Niners also boast a good defense.

So could a deal be struck between the Eagles and Niners? If so, at what cost?

Though the 49ers have two first-round choices in next month's draft, Sando wonders if the Niners could acquire McNabb from the Eagles for, say, a second-round choice in the 2010 draft?

Writes Sando: "The 49ers already have two first-round choices. They could draft the offensive tackle they need and still get a potential starter at another position. The Eagles already have an extra third-round choice. An additional second-rounder would leave them with five choices in the first three rounds, tied with the Browns for the most in the league.

"Let's look at this deal from an NFC West perspective. Would the Cardinals, Seahawks and Rams rather face the 49ers with McNabb or the 49ers with Smith and whichever player San Francisco drafted in the second round? I think they'd rather take their chances with Smith and the 2010 second-rounder.

Interesting fit but do the birds deal him within the conference?  For a 1st rounder - Hell yes.

[ice grillin you]

But, my opinion says that if McNabb is traded, the Eagles will not only NOT get to the Super Bowl in the next five (maybe ten) years, but  they won't even sniff the same winning percentage or number of championship games that they did with McNabb in charge of the field.  

pretty ballsy predicition there

my predicition is that they will have a horrible winning % and will only be in one superbowl in the next five years but they will win it