2010 Point & Laugh at the skins thread

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

You clearly have a very loose definition of intelligence.

Athletic?  Yes.
Strong?  Yes.
Smart?  Ha.

[ice grillin you]

well i dont know how he is at geometry but hes definitely football smart and overall seems like a pretty smart guy...i mean just normal intelligence like your average person...not trying to say hes a mensa member but of all the athletes in the world mcnabb is probably in the bottom 20 of ones youd call ridiculously dumb

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Explain how he's football smart.  Seriously.  He had two reads: the primary one and throwing it away.

[ice grillin you]

he ran a super complicated offense at high level for a decade

i dont even wanna have this conversation

your comment is so incredibly off base its making me defend someone i despise

[PhillyPhreak54]

Keep provoking him, FF. I wanna see him defend McNabb more.

[ice grillin you]

screw off texan

[PhillyPhreak54]

lol

That doesn't cut me as deep as defending 5 does for you.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

We'll see how smart he is working in Shanny's offense this year.

[General_Failure]

He didn't know the overtime rules. Stop being such a damned hippo IGY.

[ice grillin you]

i really dont even know how to respond to anyone who thinks donovan mcnabb is stupid....you i expect it from as you arent a sports guy...ff tho shocks me because i never pegged him as hating him that much

[ice grillin you]

We'll see how smart he is working in Shanny's offense this year.

shanny offense is a pretty straight forward system...especially for supposedly being west coastish

i expect mcnabb to have the same problems he always had with accuracy...clock management intestinal fortitude ect....but hes not going to not understand it...hes been running either a d1 football offense or a highly sophisticated pro offense for basically half his life

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

I really don't hate him.  Most athletes aren't smart.  He's a notch lower than most.  He's a guy who, at his peak, was preposterously strong and fast, with a strong arm.  None of that added up to brains.  Even most of his biggest fans wouldn't call him a cerebral guy.

[ice grillin you]

and not any of his biggest haters would call him ridiculously dumb....in fact until today i have never in my life even heard his intelligence brought up in any capacity good or bad....is he peyton manning no....is he ryan leaf no

if manning is a 10 and leaf a 1 mcnabb is probably a 6 or 7...again you cant be below average intelligence and put up the numbers he did in reids offense...an offense that has eaten up many a pass catcher with its complexities

in terms of the real world he seems to be a regular well spoken college graduate no different than most people on this board...i mean if hes ridiculously dumb then what are we?

[Diomedes]

we need some games to talk about, this shtein is killing me

[MDS]

my cats pee lumps keep clogging up my toilet

there