Can We All Finally Agree Donovan Needs To Burn In Hell (even you phreak)

[Sgt PSN]

mcnabb's been fat for a couple years now.  he did seem to slim down a bit the last 2 seasons but from 04-07, dude was busting at the seams in his uniform. 

[MDS]

phreak just admit you want to stroke donovans schlong and be done with it

[Tomahawk]

I heard he also raped three 12 year old girls, and killed 84 kittens by throwing footballs at a target 3 inches to their right.

The kittens were killed because he was throwing at a target 10 yards further downfield than them

[PhillyPhreak54]

mcnabb's been fat for a couple years now.  he did seem to slim down a bit the last 2 seasons but from 04-07, dude was busting at the seams in his uniform. 

So a ripped 240 is fat?

MDS...don't be jealous.

[MDS]

your homerism for him knows no bounds. you are literally the only person on earth besides wilma that liked his air guitar and plexiglass hump. nothing is his fault, its always someone else. but i have to admit, he probably has a nice dong.

[Sgt PSN]

mcnabb's been fat for a couple years now.  he did seem to slim down a bit the last 2 seasons but from 04-07, dude was busting at the seams in his uniform. 

So a ripped 240 is fat?

MDS...don't be jealous.

like i said, the last 2 years he's trimmed a few inches around his midriff.  but for a while there, dude was starting to look like wilma.

[ice grillin you]

i wouldnt say hes fat but hes definitely pudgy and whatever anyone thinks he is he definitely isnt "ripped"

[Don Ho]

how is mcnabb black

he eats campbell's soup, not progresso.

Yeah, but Campbell's makes a Healthy Request Soup.  Low cal, low carb, full of nutritious vegetables.  Just what a fat ass needs.

[LBIggle]

chubby chasers

[NC_Eagle]

more successful would mean have won a superbowl?

i would contend he had ample opportunity to win one and if he had it in him to do so he would have

I was thinking more overall consistency in his game, but as you point out winning Superbowls is the ultimate goal.
So in that point of view McNabb's career is exactly as successful as Dan Marino's.



*ducks and covers* 

[ice grillin you]

more successful would mean have won a superbowl?

i would contend he had ample opportunity to win one and if he had it in him to do so he would have

I was thinking more overall consistency in his game, but as you point out winning Superbowls is the ultimate goal.
So in that point of view McNabb's career is exactly as successful as Dan Marino's.



*ducks and covers* 

my point is he was on the cusp of six of them...meaning he was good enough to just about get there but not quite more than that...meaning if he was 'more successful' that would have meant at least one title

[Munson]

I like how it's him that was "just good enough to get there but not win it" and never the rest of the team or the coach. It's always just McNabb.

[ice grillin you]

no you dont like it...you hate it with all your white trash might


anyway its the coach as well....but this isnt a burn in hell andy reid thread...take your ass there if this thread hurts your feelings

[Munson]

The thread doesn't hurt my feelings. The idiocy from you dolts is kind of disturbing though.

[JackStraw]

I think it all boils down to whether one believes ReidCo can instantly and regularly win 10 games a season without McNabb. And frankly that test is coming one day soon regardless.

Would a couple or three seasons of close but no cigar be OK using Cobbsy? For me yep, as I'm at the point where that is preferable to stasis. I believe a new QB will force a change to ReidCos game plan. To me this is what is needed. Reid ain't going nowhere. Losing McNabb brings some trepidation, but it needs to be done and the cowpuke ass raping brings it sooner IMO.

Too bad it won't be in 2010.