Go on the record - Who is your starting QB?

[Feva]

Here's the deal.

A couple weeks ago, I would have told you Vick for 2010 and beyond. Based on the last 2 weeks though, now I say Kolb -2010, Kolb - 2011. It's not because of me flip-flopping, it's because of how I think Andy operates. I think these Niners and Falcons games sealed Vick's long term future here much like the Chiefs/Saints game sealed the deal with McNabb last year. Those games just solidified Andy's belief in Kolb going forward and now I don't see Andy turning away from his hand-picked QB of the future in order to extend Vick, who's still a bit of an unknown. That being said, if Kolb will be your QB in 2011, which I think he will...then he should be your QB in 2010. As exciting as it is to watch Vick, it's just a waste of time to play him over Kolb if you've got no future plans for him. Besides the fact that playing him more would likely decrease his trade value because it really can't get much higher.

[Magical_Retard]

everybody loves everybodyRaymond!

That show is funnier than King of Queens

Debra

[SD]

There's a lot of talk about the upcoming trade deadline and the Eagles QBs. Hypothetically a team makes you an offer for Vick or Kolb. So my question is: What would you take - right now - for Kolb?
Same question but for Vick.

The Eagles stance is they're happy with both guys so any team that's going to get either QB is going to have to give good compensation. Honestly I wouldn't take anything lower than a 2nd for Vick, and wouldn't take anything other than a mid first and maybe a later round pick for Kolb.

[ice grillin you]

two numbers ones for either and id do it....which is to say i wouldnt trade either of them

[Eagaholic]

I wouldn't make a trade, they'll need both. They have a chance of bumbling their way into the playoffs but neither qb is likely to stay healthy even through the next 5 games much less the rest of the season. For an unpossible deal like 2 number 1s I'd do it though.

[rjs246]

Any team desperate for a QB mid-season is likely to have a pretty high draft pick come April. I take a #1 for either, preferably Vick.

[smeags]

Any team desperate for a QB mid-season is likely to have a pretty high draft pick come April. I take a #1 for either, preferably Vick.

this

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Isn't the trade deadline today?

[joneszilla]

Isn't the trade deadline today?

yes

[Eagles_Legendz]

Missanelli was basically brow beating Bruno because Bruno thought they could get a #1 pick for one of them yesterday.

I'm not sure they could get one for Vick with him having a year left on his deal, but I think with how many horrendous QB situations there are out there, they could most likely get a #1 for Kolb from someone.

[ice grillin you]

aj feely went for a second

[Eagles_Legendz]

exactly.

Jason Campbell, Matt Moore, Ryan Fitzpatrick, Alex Smith, and David Gerrard are all starting with no real viable alternatives.  Colt McCoy is going to blow too.

A #1, even a high one, would be justified if any of those teams thought Kolb or Vick (if they could sign him), were legitimate options as their future.  Obviously Kolb would probably be preferable for those teams since none of them are close to winning now, so presumably it'll take a few years, though with how zesty the NFL is in general right now, you never know.

[ice grillin you]

vick is ideal for a place like carolina or jacksonville that dont draw and need a qb....he would pay for himself in attention and attendance alone

[SD]

Missanelli was basically brow beating Bruno because Bruno thought they could get a #1 pick for one of them yesterday.

I'm not sure they could get one for Vick with him having a year left on his deal, but I think with how many horrendous QB situations there are out there, they could most likely get a #1 for Kolb from someone.

I'd never question Roseman again if he could get a #1 for Vick. I honestly think he's worth it, he's playing at a borderline Pro Bowl/MVP level, and has at least 4 or 5 good seasons left in him. I would have taken a 2nd and been happy. Maybe try to flip that for Logan Mankins. For Kolb I'd hold out for a 1st and maybe a 3rd, just because he's a little younger.

[ice grillin you]

trade deadline passed 120 seconds ago...

thank god