Go on the record - Who is your starting QB?

[smeags]

They're def NOT winning this year.

so then start the guy who is more exciting as opposed to letting the so-called "future" develope.

[Munson]

Okay, I get it. He's black and you don't want him running around making plays. My bad.

[smeags]

not sure how anyone who isn't purposely trying to stir the pot or is a retard could think kolb's play hasn't been exciting to watch the last couple of weeks.

which do you fall under ?

[Munson]

So, again, are you saying that Kevin Kolb is more exciting to watch play than Mike Vick? especially with the way Vick played as a starter?


If you're getting more big plays made (which Vick was doing/what he probably will still do) and still winning....then you go with Vick. But if he shows that it was just a mirage and he's actually Vick from the Falcons, tell him it's over. It's not that hard.

[Tomahawk]

2010 Kolb
2011 Kolb
2012 MCNABB! [\phillyphreak]

[mussa]

Too tough to say at this point. Both guys need more games under their belts before any fair judgment can be given out. The Oline showed up yesterday and Kolb shined. The Oline plays like shtein, it's pretty much Vick's position. I vote for whatever gets Reid fired quicker.

[phillymic2000]

Wtf munson? So if some of us want Kolb then were racist against the bnrother man? Kolb went 23-29 362 yds! Vick led the Eagles to 2 straight wins and they benched the cracker. So now that the cracker is lighting it up, without Pimp for a whole half. How do u sit him!!! Kolb for 2010,2011,2012 etc.

[Drunkmasterflex]

This is a really tough question.  I guess I go with Kolb because he is likely your future.  Either way they better Franchise Vick in the off season and get something for him. 

[Munson]

lol holy shtein phillymic calm down broseph. It was just a smartass comment.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

2010 Kolb
2011 Kolb
2012 MCNABB! [\phillyphreak]

I laughed.  But McNabb is a FA after this season, so it would be much more accurate if you slotted Donnie Mac for 2011.

[General_Failure]

He'll have to sit on the bench of a year to relearn the system.

[MMH]

I believe Vick is a short term solution.  You know pretty much what you got, and can sign him to 2-3 year contract at the end of the season IF.....

Kolb sucks.  However, you'll only know that if you give the kid a try.  That was the plan, and Reid uncharacteristically didn't stick to it.  Kolb looked lost against GB and hide your eyes awful against Washington.  Better against SF and Atlanta.  But I believe he needs a season to prove it.  Hopefully, he does and you get some for trading Vick.  If not, hang onto Vick, show Kolb the door, and draft another guy for the future.

[PhillyPhreak54]

2010 Kolb
2011 Kolb
2012 MCNABB! [\phillyphreak]

I laughed.  But McNabb is a FA after this season, so it would be much more accurate if you slotted Donnie Mac for 2011.

As did I. 

Vick
TBD

I can't call it for 2011 yet. I have been pleasantly surprised by what Kolb has shown these last two weeks. Because after the pre-season, Packers quarter and taterskins game I was doubting more than ever.

However, with the state of this OL I would continue to start Vick based on that and some of the defensive lines/pass rushers they have coming up.

It is a good problem to have and I think both are handling it perfectly.

[Diomedes]

everybody loves everybody!

[Munson]

everybody loves everybodyRaymond!

That show is funnier than King of Queens