Brian Dawkins, ex-Eagle

[Tomahawk]

That reminds me, FastFreddie, I can't believe the Eagles just let Dawkins walk

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

That reminds me, FastFreddie, I can't believe the Eagles just let Dawkins walk

They what?!?  When the farg did this happen?

[reese125]

I think you're positioning yourself to want something you know the FO won't do so you can continue to rail against them for a couple years when Cutler has a good season.

we know they wont but its for arguments sake--something CF hates to do

that said-- I put my hand up in the Cutler thread weeks back

While I say that McNabb is the safe pick because we know what he brings to the table as far as turnovers, wins and such--do you really in your heart of hearts think he can bring you a championship after all these years? If you do than fine, but I would say majority in here say no just by past posts alone and what has happened in the past 10 years

Can you say the same about Cutler--absolutely not.  Id take him with the quickness to secure my franchise chinless or not

[ice grillin you]

its more about the next ten years than it is this year...but even right now its at best a draw and i think id currently take cutler over mcnabb

[General_Failure]

I just want to punch Cutler in his sagging chicken neck.

his gizzard?

Russel likes the cut of his giblets.

[Father Demon]

Yes, McNabb could, provided.... 

It never has been about the talent of McNabb, it's been about the talent of Thrash, GLew, McMullin, and Freddy.  It's been about the pass-run ratio.  It's been about piss poor clock management. 

What makes you think Cutler would be anymore successful than McNabb given the "strategy" of the FO and coaching system that has been in place for 10 years, and will stay in place until changes are made at that level rather than the quarterback level?

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Reese and IGY agree on something.  April Fool's Day indeed.

[ice grillin you]

What makes you think Cutler would be anymore successful than McNabb given the "strategy" of the FO and coaching system that has been in place for 10 years, and will stay in place until changes are made at that level rather than the quarterback level?

for one we dont know if cutler pukes in big games...get cutler to five nfc championship games and ill take my chances that he wins a title....hes also a more accurate qb that fits andys offense better than donovan...hes also way younger not near his prime yet and is still arguably as good or better than mcnabb right now

[General_Failure]

for one we dont know if cutler pukes in big games

Because he can't get to them.

get cutler to five nfc championship games and ill take my chances that he wins a title

Which makes him nearly as good as McNabb in that area, if we take into account that Cutler would have to be carried to them in the first place.

hes also a more accurate qb that fits andys offense better than donovan

His interceptions say no.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Could the Eagles keep McNabb as a fullback?

Remember how great it worked out when they tried to relegate Cunningham to WR?

[ice grillin you]

for one we dont know if cutler pukes in big games

Because he can't get to them.

hes also a more accurate qb that fits andys offense better than donovan

His interceptions say no.

lol hes played three years....theres a lot more that goes into being accurate than interceptions...the willingness to take chances...youth ect...id rather have a higher completion % with more interceptions than the other way around

but i see youre just arguing to argue...to be fine with dawkins (who had a better year at safety than mcnabb did at qb) being replaced by i dont know who but not wanting jay cutler just shows the argumentative nature of some

[rjs246]

But wait, what about this scenario:

FF offers to piss on your face for free while Brian Dawkins tapdances to showtunes in the corner and you have $10,000 in your pants.

What about that?

[Sgt PSN]

high fiving and throwing at the same time?  i'm impressed now.  GET CUTLER!!

[rjs246]

I'm more impressed with his 5 inch neckchin. It's mesmerizing.

[Sgt PSN]

What makes you think Cutler would be anymore successful than McNabb given the "strategy" of the FO and coaching system that has been in place for 10 years, and will stay in place until changes are made at that level rather than the quarterback level?

for one we dont know if cutler pukes in big games

that's because he has yet to lead his team to a big game.  biggest game he played in so far was the choke job against san diego last year to close out the season.