A Decade of Andy Reid

[DH]

I disagree on Lewis. He was a solid player till the New Orleans game in 06' when he blew coverage against Horn and Reid never gave him another shot again.

Reid's fault; not Lewis'. In fact, had Reid not misplayed that situation, I think Lewis would still be here...would have obviously meant Mikell would be elsewhere, but nevertheless, farg you Reid.

[ice grillin you]

They actually used Pinkston as an excuse not to upgrade the STARTING lineup.  Awful.

huh?...they made by far their biggest upgrade at the position when they had pinkston and he actually had a very good year when they did

pinkston was what he was...the hate he got took on a life of its own and was so far over the top that by the end it became completely ridiculous

he was a solid nfl'er and does not belong on a list with the other truly horrific players mentioned here

[DH]

Solid? C'mon homey, I'd cringe to even call him average.

After his performance against Carolina and his "losing in the lights" bullshtein, his ticket out of Philly was essentially punched. They had no choice but to upgrade. I've always thought if Pinkston wouldnt have performed as poorly as he did in that game and the team wins and goes to the SB, Owens never wears an Eagles jersey.

[PhillyGirl]

They actually used Pinkston as an excuse not to upgrade the STARTING lineup.  Awful.

huh?...they made by far their biggest upgrade at the position when they had pinkston and he actually had a very good year when they did

pinkston was what he was...the hate he got took on a life of its own and was so far over the top that by the end it became completely ridiculous

he was a solid nfl'er and does not belong on a list with the other truly horrific players mentioned here

I hate to agree with this, but I will.

He was never a #1. He was shoved into that position and it wasnt his fault.

[DH]

If he wasn't supposed to be a number #1 - especially when as a rookie, he played on a team that only had Charles Johnson, Torrance Small and Na Brown as receivers, why exactly was he drafted in the top of the 2nd round?

Again, farg Ried.

[PhillyPhreak54]

Andy is full of shtein.

Mike Lewis sucked in coverage; we knew that, they knew that and he knew that. He was a helluva in the box guy. But with Dawk getting up there, you couldn't have two in the box guys on the field at the same time.

Thank goodness for Mikell developing into a solid player.

[rjs246]

Mikell has had one solid year as a pro. One. Let's not go jerking each others' dicks around just yet.

[DH]

But with Dawk getting up there, you couldn't have two in the box guys on the field at the same time.

The thing is though Dawk still had one of his best years last season...3 years removed from Lewis' last full season as an Eagle. So if that was their reasoning, again, another miscalculation for Andy and the FO.

One year or not, I'm on the Mikell wagon.

[ice grillin you]

Solid? C'mon homey, I'd cringe to even call him average.

After his performance against Carolina and his "losing in the lights" bullshtein, his ticket out of Philly was essentially punched. They had no choice but to upgrade. I've always thought if Pinkston wouldnt have performed as poorly as he did in that game and the team wins and goes to the SB, Owens never wears an Eagles jersey.

he was better than greg lewis but not as good as say kevin curtis...what im saying is he shouldnt be lumped in with guys like matt mccoy who should have never even been in the league to begin with and i think thats what we were doing...naming complete train wrecks under andy...

i am by no means defending pinky i just think the uproar over todd pinkston was much worse than todd pinkston...i mean after time it almost became a fable that was handed down generation to generation with new stuff added to it to the point it just became outrageous

[General_Failure]

Pinkston tried to throw snowballs at Santa, but his frail noodle arms just couldn't get him the distance he needed.

[Seabiscuit36]

Mikell has had one solid year as a pro. One. Let's not go jerking each others' dicks around just yet.

thanks for telling me now

[rjs246]

I heard that Todd Pinkston threw car batteries at Santa and raped Mike Schmidt.

[ice grillin you]

with his wig and groucho marx sunglasses on

[General_Failure]

I heard that Todd Pinkston threw car batteries at Santa and raped Mike Schmidt.

Can you blame him? Schmidt threw him out trying to reach first base so many times, he was bound to snap.

[DH]

In an attempt to get this thread back on track: farg you Andy Reid.