Eagles - NFC East Champs

[BlueHeart]

The devil made him do it.

[ice grillin you]

i thought LT was a vegetarian?

[rjs246]

you dont win coach of the year for realizing how bad of a coach you are

Just reading this thread. And this quote should be branded on the forehead of everyone who thinks Andy Reid should win anything other than a oneway ticket out of town.

[Wingspan]

wah

vince young

[Feva]

maybe

but he called the steelers last year

He calls the Steelers every year.

The real scary thing is a few days ago... Hoge called us the best team in the NFC. 

[Yeti]

Just reading this thread. And this quote should be branded on the forehead of everyone who thinks Andy Reid should win anything other than a oneway ticket out of town.

Crazy talk.  The should rip down the Rocky statue and put up one of Big Red.  Best fargin thing to ever happen to this team.

[General_Failure]

Best thing he did was draft McNabb. The only other good thing was be the coach when Westbrook was drafted.

[mpmcgraw]

i want a ring

Unless Spadaro's ring ends up on ebay again or 20 years down the road one of the players is poor and needs crack money I do not like your chances.

Plus there's that whole the Eagles have to actually win a superbowl thing too. 

[shorebird]

Just reading this thread. And this quote should be branded on the forehead of everyone who thinks Andy Reid should win anything other than a oneway ticket out of town.

Crazy talk.  The should rip down the Rocky statue and put up one of Big Red.  Best fargin thing to ever happen to this team.

Reid's offense is winning games with Jeff Garcia at qb, and people still want to fire him. Ugh. Yes, he no longer calls plays, but who's playbook is Marty calling the plays from?? Whose offense is it?? Whose team?

It's Reids team, from top to bottom. Does he get any credit for drafting Andrews, or making the deal that brought Runyan here, or anything in between?

I honestly believe that if by some miracle we with the NFC Championship and go to the Superbowl, that there would still be those with hardwood heads that would want to fire him.

[ice grillin you]

Reid's offense is winning games with Jeff Garcia at qb, and people still want to fire him. Ugh. Yes, he no longer calls plays, but who's playbook is Marty calling the plays from?? Whose offense is it?? Whose team?

i have no problem with his play design...ive always gave him much credit for that...which is also why ive always said the best spot for him would be an assistant offensive coach...someone who draws up plays but doesnt actually call them...he has no business being on an nfl sideline on sundays

[shorebird]

he has no business being on an nfl sideline on sundays

He's won as many or more games as any coach since he's been on the sidelines, yet he has no business being there.  

I'll give him the benefit of the doubt for now and see how everything plays out next year when Dmac comes back. Everyone might as well give up the 'Fire Reid' argument. If and when he does stop coaching, it will probably be to GM this team. Not that I agree with the divine devotion that Lurie seems to have for Reid, I guarantee you that he's cemented his feet as coach with his owner. We lost one of the most dangerous offensive weapons in the game, but are still winning with a team everyone had written off. Winning with a qb who a lot of people except Reid, me included, thought was done like Burnell. Winning because he has enough talent on this team, and a good enough game plan in place to take a season ending injury to the Franchise player and still win games this team had no business winning. We swept the friggen' division on the road, in three straight games!! The three teams that were supposed to make the NFC East so damn good. Our third string qb passed for over three hundred yards against Atlanta's starters!!

Lurie is not firing Reid. If he did he would look like the biggest idiot in the NFL. imo, he would be too. You don't fire Andy Ried now, with what has transpired the past few years. Maybe you ask him if he'd be interesting in General Managing full time, but you don't fire him.

[SunMo]

yeah, he got them out of a 5-6 hole and they won the division, but you have to take into account that he was the main reason they were in that hole.  not until he gave up play calling duties did the season turn around. 

he's not a good game day coach, that much is clear.  he excels in the preparation work done during the week leading up to a game. 

also, he's accumulated many of his wins against a terrible division and substandard conference for many years.

[Wingspan]

the defense put them in the 5-6 hole more than anything else.

[ice grillin you]

also, he's accumulated many of his wins against a terrible division and substandard conference for many years.

thats pretty much it...like i said the other day his record vs winning teams is atrocious...and its sick how many times hes been urinated on by an opposing coach in a big game

[Wingspan]

also, he's accumulated many of his wins against a terrible division and substandard conference for many years.

what good coach wouldnt?