Start Feeley

[SunMo]

garcia hasn't been an effective quarterback in 3 years

[Susquehanna Birder]

The fact that he lead the Niners to the playoffs 5 years ago shouldn't factor into what he can do now.

We'll see...but I tend to agree with you. He knows the offense, but his arm is probably best suited for holding a clipboard.

[hunt]

aj hasn't be an effective qb ever.

[SunMo]

aj hasn't be an effective qb ever.

4-1...seemed pretty effective then

[ice grillin you]

aj had a couple decent games 4 years ago...garcia is much more proven if they're thinking win now to make the playoffs.

that only makes sense if right now it was four years ago

aj has been in this exact same situation before and DID IT


just because youre older doesnt mean youre better...age is only an advantage when youre talking about a rookie or a guy whos never started in the nfl...and its a disadvantage when youre 36 and cant play anymore

the only thing that garcia has 'proven' is that hes finished

[MURP]

garcia hasn't been an effective quarterback in 3 years

considering the teams he was with you cant be that surprised. 

[Wingspan]

aj hasn't be an effective qb ever.

4-1...seemed pretty effective then

3-8...seemed pretty ineffective then

[Wingspan]

i understand the it doesnt matter crowd and im not preaching a playoff berth or anything but dont you think its fundamentally wrong to start a lesser player when youre one game out of the division just because your OC is freinds with him and told him to come to philly

i mean no one truly believes that reid thinks garcia gives them a better chance to win do they?

everyone seems to forget that feeley actually sucks. he was beaten out by 2 guys who never played an NFL game before this past summer.

i think garcia gives them a better chance to win. it's not leaps and bounds. but a better chance nonetheless.

[SD_Eagle5]

I hope Freeney sacks Garcia and he dislocates his elbow. De Ja Vu is a bitch.

[hunt]

aj hasn't be an effective qb ever.

4-1...seemed pretty effective then

you know better than that...the team won but aj did nothing.  go back & look up his stats.
the D carried that team.

[SunMo]

yeah, he had a team full of offensive weapons in Miami, didn't he?

[SD_Eagle5]

i understand the it doesnt matter crowd and im not preaching a playoff berth or anything but dont you think its fundamentally wrong to start a lesser player when youre one game out of the division just because your OC is freinds with him and told him to come to philly

i mean no one truly believes that reid thinks garcia gives them a better chance to win do they?

everyone seems to forget that feeley actually sucks. he was beaten out by 2 guys who never played an NFL game before this past summer.

i think garcia gives them a better chance to win. it's not leaps and bounds. but a better chance nonetheless.

Feeley thrived in this system, I don't care what he did with the Dolphins or Chargers. Garcia sucks, he's sucked since he left the Niners.

[rjs246]

This argument is idiotic. They both suck. One is younger and should be given a chance because this season is OVER.

[SunMo]

its no doubt that we're arguing between who's  the better lay...the fat chick or the handicapped chick.  but in that discussion, it's somewhat obvious that Feely is the better option.

[Wingspan]

yeah, he had a team full of offensive weapons in Miami, didn't he?

Randy McMichael, Chris Chambers, and Marty Booker were better than Todd Pinkston, James Thrash and Chad Lewis