Start Feeley

[MURP]

well they did sign Garcia to be the #2 QB... whats the big deal? 

[SunMo]

he sucks?  hard?

[ice grillin you]

i dont think feely is great by any means but he gives them a much better chance to win and garcia wouldnt even be on the team had feely been available at the time

then again reid played joselio hanson over rod hood so i dont think he is really that concerned with putting the best possible team on the field

[Diomedes]

There is nothing to be gained by starting Garcia.  He's Blake, McMahon, etc.  Let him hold that backup spot for in game replacement of an injured QB. 

Put Feeley out there and see what he can do.  He might even make the team for next year if he wins a few.  Garcia is worthless at this point..no upside at all, certainly doens't offer a better chance of winning now.

[SD_Eagle5]

well they did sign Garcia to be the #2 QB... whats the big deal? 

If Feeley were available at the time I doubt Garcia would have been signed to be the #2.

[SunMo]

also, remember they were comapring the new #2 to Mike McMahon.  at that point, Dennis Byrd lookied like a great option at #2 QB.

[ice grillin you]

gargano just confirmed garcia will be starting

[SD_Eagle5]

gargano just confirmed garcia will be starting

What a load of shtein. I hope Andy chokes on his Thanksgiving dinner.

[Philly_Crew]

gargano just confirmed garcia will be starting

What a load of shtein. I hope Andy chokes on his Thanksgiving dinner.

The more I think about it, I don't mind one start by Garcia to see what he can do with a full week of practice.  If he looks as jumpy and weak-armed as last week, then start Feeley.

[SunMo]

The more I think about it, I don't mind one start by Garcia to see what he can do with a full week of practice.  If he looks as jumpy and weak-armed as last week, then start Feeley.

but this is the playoff push!  they don't have one game to waste!

[Quasimoto]

Who cares who starts?  McNabb went down so did the season. 

It wouldn't of mattered anyway.  We have Stay-Puft running the team into the ground.

[ice grillin you]

i understand the it doesnt matter crowd and im not preaching a playoff berth or anything but dont you think its fundamentally wrong to start a lesser player when youre one game out of the division just because your OC is freinds with him and told him to come to philly

i mean no one truly believes that reid thinks garcia gives them a better chance to win do they?

[SD_Eagle5]

I can accept the fact that the seasons over, what I can't accept

gargano just confirmed garcia will be starting

What a load of shtein. I hope Andy chokes on his Thanksgiving dinner.

The more I think about it, I don't mind one start by Garcia to see what he can do with a full week of practice. If he looks as jumpy and weak-armed as last week, then start Feeley.

Unless they pumped him full of Steroids this past week none of that is going to change. He's still gonna run out of the pocket the first chance he gets, and his arm is done. It's been done. The fact that he lead the Niners to the playoffs 5 years ago shouldn't factor into what he can do now.

At least with AJ you have a younger guy with a strong arm who can build a future to be a solid #2 for 5-10 years.

[hunt]

i mean no one truly believes that reid thinks garcia gives them a better chance to win do they?

yes.
aj had a couple decent games 4 years ago...garcia is much more proven if they're thinking win now to make the playoffs.
personally, i didn't think they'd make the playoffs with mcnabb, let alone garcia, but i guess they have to try.

[Quasimoto]

i understand the it doesnt matter crowd and im not preaching a playoff berth or anything but dont you think its fundamentally wrong to start a lesser player when youre one game out of the division just because your OC is freinds with him and told him to come to philly

i mean no one truly believes that reid thinks garcia gives them a better chance to win do they?

We don't know who gives us the best chance and neither did Andy last week because apparently no one was getting any snaps with the first team. 

The only thing that would make this interesting is if they put the rookies in like they did last year.  Then at least we'd have some more incentive to see what we have next year.