Start Feeley

[SD_Eagle5]

I'll detract from saying he 'thrived' because stat wise I can't back it up, but he was 4-1 as the starter, he's not 47 years old and won't scramble out of the pocket at the first sign of pressure. Garcia sucks. He was an awful F/A signing. If Feeley had been available he's not on the team.

[Diomedes]

I don't see how Feeley offers a worse chance of winning the game this weekend.

I don't see how the investment made in starting Garcia offers a better chance of positive long term returns.

I do however understand the comment "who cares which one starts."  That's true, so I'm not gonna get worked up about farging Garcia.

Whatever, Andy.

[MURP]

I do however understand the comment "who cares which one starts."  That's true, so I'm not gonna get worked up about farging Garcia.

Whatever, Andy.

word to that. 

[SunMo]

yeah, sounds about right

[hunt]

he's shown he's not Jeff Garcia...who doesn't belong in the league

don't worry...aj will get his chance in a couple weeks when the eagles are out of contention.

[ice grillin you]

agreed

im still salty over the hood thing and i just dont want garcia starting cause hes martys boy and because he got him here he feels as tho he has to start

if andy truly believes garcia is the better choice then hes an idiot but i can live with that....but if its some shady shtein like the hood thing and the best guy is not starting for reasons other than football then farg that

[phattymatty]

i'd rather argue about which one of them is banging the hotter chick.  it's pretty close.

[Diomedes]

an excellent idea.

which one of you dorks wants to put up some pics?

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Carmela Decesare (Garcia's chick)
There are plenty more pics of her that are less safe for work.

Heather Mitts (Feeley's chick)
Plenty more available, but no boobage.

[rjs246]

i'd rather argue about which one of them is banging the hotter chick. it's pretty close.

I don't think its remotely close. Garcia's beard is WAY hotter than Feeley's beard.

(Come on, you don't actually think that either of them are straight, do you? High pitched, lispy voices. Over the top public attractive girlfriends. Noodle arms...)

[PhillyPhreak54]

Poor choice by Andy.

I hope he has a quick hook. Or that Jeff breaks an ankle.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Or that Jeff breaks an ankle.

What was the year we had guys like Brad Goebel, Dave Archer, and Jeff Kemp taking snaps?

Let's totally go back to that!

[PhillyPhreak54]

Or that Jeff breaks an ankle.

What was the year we had guys like Brad Goebel, Dave Archer, and Jeff Kemp taking snaps?

Let's totally go back to that!

1991, I believe.

[shorebird]

Poor choice by Andy.

I hope he has a quick hook. Or that Jeff breaks an ankle.

I just do not understand what that hardheaded bitch is thinking. My 15 year old High Schooler can tell Garcia is done. Is Reid just giving up on the whole season?? 22 incompletions weren't enough for him?? You supposedly have a offense geared to the big deep play. Wouldn't you want a qb who can throw the ball farther than 20 yds. downfield?? I'm baffled by this decision.

Remember when we signed Feeley, and I was campaining for him to move up on the depth chart ahead of Garcia?? It was said that discussion of who would be the second and third string qb was ridiculous and stupid. Now, here is a whole thread dedicated to the subject.

all you people who ridiculed me, you know who you are.

[shorebird]

Great, just great.

"He's the quarterback and there's not a short leash," Reid said. "I brought Jeff in here for this situation, if something were to happen to Donovan. I have a lot of trust in Jeff. I have a lot of trust in A.J., too, but I brought Jeff in for this reason. He's a pretty good quarterback."