McNabb's Remark

[ice grillin you]

Dude, bad QBs have won a SB


"this isnt a knock on mcnabb in anyway...he simply isnt a great qb...however good qb's have won the sb"

[SD_Eagle5]

Those comparisons are a complete joke and you know it.

they really arent

but if you need to say clayton and duper were great wr's in order artifically inflate mcnabb then knock yourself out

unless he wins a sb mcnabb is just another very good qb in this league...hes in with a hundred others of his kind...hes joe theisman without a superbowl...hes not even on the same planet as the the elways and marinos...

Compare McNabbs career stats to Elways, tell me where the overwhelming difference lies. And Elway only went on to win a SB because he had one of the most dominant running attacks in recent history.

Clayton/Duper were good receivers, up to this point Donovan's had crap. Lets see, Freddie left the team and went on to do what? Thrash? Johnson? Small?

[reese125]

I think this is funny how all of sudden anyone said Mcnabb sucked. Hes just been disappointing in alot of ways--as well as exciting...so easy fellas. hug it out...bring it in for the real thing

[hunt]

yep...not one person said he sucks.
i think he's very good....but not great.  to be great, you either have to win a super bowl or put up astronomical statistics...mcnabb hasn't done either yet.  i hope he does.

[ice grillin you]

lolol...its so true

mcnabb has to be the best qb ever or youre a hater

[SD_Eagle5]

lolol...its so true

mcnabb has to be the best qb ever or youre a hater

Nope, but why is he scrutinized moreso than any other QB in the league? Thats what I want to know. Ever hear this crap about Manning? How bout any other QB?

[hunt]

lolol...its so true

mcnabb has to be the best qb ever or youre a hater

Nope, but why is he scrutinized moreso than any other QB in the league? Thats what I want to know. Ever hear this crap about Manning? How bout any other QB?

duh.
because he's black.

[SD_Eagle5]

lolol...its so true

mcnabb has to be the best qb ever or youre a hater

Nope, but why is he scrutinized moreso than any other QB in the league? Thats what I want to know. Ever hear this crap about Manning? How bout any other QB?

duh.
because he's black.

Not according to igy

[SunMo]

i don't hear this stuff about McNabb nationally, only locally.  and if you don't think Peyton gets this shtein in Indy, you're kidding yourself.  every QB in every football city is under scrutiny.

[hunt]

i don't hear this stuff about McNabb nationally, only locally.  and if you don't think Peyton gets this shtein in Indy, you're kidding yourself.  every QB in every football city is under scrutiny.

i was going to post something similar but i went with the because he's black joke instead.

[SunMo]

funny, i was going to do a black joke, but went with a serious answer instead.

[SD_Eagle5]

i don't hear this stuff about McNabb nationally, only locally.  and if you don't think Peyton gets this shtein in Indy, you're kidding yourself.  every QB in every football city is under scrutiny.

Are you kidding me? McNabb's been scrutinized nationally more so than Manning, its not even close. Whether it be race, his play, TO, or something minor he's said like "I'm not here to make friends". If Manning had come out and said that you're telling me Colts fans would actually give a shtein?

[SunMo]

where do you hear this national scrutiny?  because i sure as hell don't hear it.  and Peyton was getting killed nationally after they lost to the Steelers, especially for his comment about not throwing guys under the bus.  you think it's more on Donovan because he's your focus, but it's not. 

[ice grillin you]

boo hoo

suck it up and win a superbowl

mcnabb is a good qb but hes a little bitch...my problem with him is not his play its does he have what it takes emotionally to win it all

philly probably was not the best place for him to go

[SD_Eagle5]

where do you hear this national scrutiny?  because i sure as hell don't hear it.  and Peyton was getting killed nationally after they lost to the Steelers, especially for his comment about not throwing guys under the bus.  you think it's more on Donovan because he's your focus, but it's not. 

In all honesty I didn't realize how bad the McNabb bashing was on a local level until I moved back here, I always thought it was more of a national opinion and that the city for the most part embraced him. Wasn't till I lived here for a month or so during the season that I saw how bad it was.

boo hoo

suck it up and win a superbowl

mcnabb is a good qb but hes a little bitch...my problem with him is not his play its does he have what it takes emotionally to win it all

philly probably was not the best place for him to go

He's handled everything from Race, to the TO fiasco, to questions about his play with class, how else would you have expected him to handle it?