Another target for a PG attack

[PhillyGirl]

IGY, stop blaming McNabb for the Rams game. Are you farging kidding me?

He's the only reason they were even IN that game. He didn't lose it. Freddie had the ball taken right out of his hands.

Blaming McNabb for that INT is farging ridiculous beyond belief.

[SunMo]

Carolina was better than people gave them credit for (they should've beaten the Eagles during the season, the kicker farged them).  Westbrook was out and Donovan got hurt.

carolina still wasnt near as good as the eagles...the fact is mcnabb played awful

i totally disagree with you there.  the recievers shtein the bed that game.  Donovan's my favorite Eagle, but I'm no apologist.  Pinkston and Thrash both got punked by Ricky Manning Jr. and Duce dropped a beautifully thrown ball down the sidelines.  Donovan had 3 picks before he got hurt, but not a single one was his fault.

[Rome]

yeah, the Tampa game wasn't a Donovan choke, it was an entire team choke.  Andy got a 7 nothing lead and tried to sit on it in the 1st quarter.  but we don't need to re-hash that.

Ding.

We have a winner.   

[SunMo]

IGY, stop blaming McNabb for the Rams game. Are you farging kidding me?

He's the only reason they were even IN that game. He didn't lose it. Freddie had the ball taken right out of his hands.

Blaming McNabb for that INT is farging ridiculous beyond belief.

Freddie didn't have the ball taken out of his hands, Williams jumped the route, but it was pretty well known that Freddie didn't run the right route on that play.

[PhillyGirl]

I know Freddie ran the wrong route. However, a better WR MAKES THAT PLAY. His hands WERE on that ball.

Point remains the same. Blaming McNabb for that pick is farging retarded.

[ice grillin you]

the recievers shtein the bed that game

the receivers sucked but you dont win games with your wr's...great qb's make plays and win games like that...mcnabb didnt do it...again tho maybe by itself you could go the wr's lost the game route...but again it hasnt been just one game

just look at yous pick apart FOUR different games and come up with an excuse or five for why he didnt win

and we havent even discussed the superbowl


funny thing is i actually like mcnabb....a lot...but lets be real here

[SunMo]

the receivers sucked but you dont win games with your wr's...great qb's make plays and win games like that...

normally, I agree with you, but you can't say that for that game.  Donovan did everything he could the players around him didn't make the plays, Trash, Pinkston, Duce.

and it's the Carolina game that I am only arguing with you on, maybe a little for the Rams game, but I saw that pick the same way I saw the pick against Washington this year, 4th down play, desperate attempt.  a pick is the same as an incomplete in those situations.

but give him credit for Atlanta, no mistakes, 2 TD passes, key 3rd down run to ice the game.  he didn't play like Peyton Manning that game, but he played a great game for that situation.

[ice grillin you]

Point remains the same. Blaming McNabb for that pick is farging retarded

you just wont ever get it...youre all to busy trying to come up with excuses as to why mcnabb is the bestest to see im not blaming him for any one pick im blaming him for not driving the team down to win that game or any of these games...again look at the big picture...a great qb at least gets to a few superbowls this decade with the eagles and should have won at least one

anyway my main point here is that a change is needed before his era is over and all this was for nothing...the one constant has been reid and mcnabb...it hasnt worked as far as getting a ring...lets try something else while they still got a chance

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

carolina = joke

Riiiight.  They had the best front 7 in all of football, a very adequate offense (especially the running game), and they tended to not make mistakes.  They would have also beat the Eagles earlier in the season if Kasay didn't take his suck pills that morning.  Hell, the guy missed a farging extra point.

[PhillyGirl]

Point remains the same. Blaming McNabb for that pick is farging retarded

you just wont ever get it...youre all to busy trying to come up with excuses as to why mcnabb is the bestest to see im not blaming him for any one pick im blaming him for not driving the team down to win that game or any of these games...again look at the big picture...a great qb at least gets to a few superbowls this decade with the eagles and should have won at least one

Sure, because that's what we're doing.

Here's an idea that I am sure quite a few on here will agree with. If you don't like it, leave.

Dan Marino blows.

[JTrotter Fan]

the receivers sucked but you dont win games with your wr's...great qb's make plays and win games like that...mcnabb didnt do it...again tho maybe by itself you could go the wr's lost the game route...but again it hasnt been just one game

That has to be the absolute dumbest statement i've ever read in my life.  "You don't win games with your wr's."  What in the farg are you thinking?  Okay, so no WR has ever helped to win a game?  You are on farging crack man.  What a dumb farg.  Geez.

[ice grillin you]

They would have also beat the Eagles earlier in the season if Kasay didn't take his suck pills that morning

well the eagles would have beaten the rams in he regular season at the vet had it not been for an opening play fumble so i guess they should have won the nfc championship game that year as well right??...dont give me that regular season nonsense...it doesnt pertain to the nfc championship game in any way

They had the best front 7 in all of football, a very adequate offense (especially the running game), and they tended to not make mistakes.

at home against carolina you MUST win that game...all things relative to that game and situation carolina was a joke...it was the reason everyone had the game banked to the eagles before it started and no revisionist history changes that


thing that hurts thru all this is that the eagles didnt lose to the 93 cowboys or the 86 giants or the 91 skins or 49ers or any historically great franchises...no they lost to the carolina panthers the tampa bay buccaneers and the friggin st louis rams...

[henchmanUK]

Point remains the same. Blaming McNabb for that pick is farging retarded

you just wont ever get it...youre all to busy trying to come up with excuses as to why mcnabb is the bestest to see im not blaming him for any one pick im blaming him for not driving the team down to win that game or any of these games...again look at the big picture...a great qb at least gets to a few superbowls this decade with the eagles and should have won at least one

Sure, because that's what we're doing.

Here's an idea that I am sure quite a few on here will agree with. If you don't like it, leave.

Dan Marino blows.

Elway sucked the big one before his last couple of seasons, too. Peyton Manning farging sucks too. And you can get that bitch Jim Kelly out of Canton too!

[ice grillin you]

Dan Marino blows

marino has a ring if hes the eagles qb these last five years....period

That has to be the absolute dumbest statement i've ever read in my life.  "You don't win games with your wr's."  What in the farg are you thinking?  Okay, so no WR has ever helped to win a game?  You are on farging crack man.  What a dumb farg.  Geez.

wow....clean up in aisle three

i never said wr's dont "help" win games...i said they dont win games for you...qb's do...qb's have the ball in their hands every play they can rise above other areas of the team not playing well...where as a wr depends on his qb

great qb's win big games and win championships...not wr's

[henchmanUK]

great qb's win big games and win championships...not wr's

GET HOSTETLER, RYPIEN AND DILFER!