Oh no...injury news

[General_Failure]

I hated Pinkston before that, and way before it was cool.

You also hate Five-Fo, who is also valuable. It's your thing.

That hate is based on his inflated stats and the run defense never being better than average.

[rjs246]

Oddly enough, I don't base my opinions on what goes on on this board.

I've said it before, I tried for years to abide his skinny ass, but he comes up small at bad times and if someone else is forced into the starting lineup (since that seems to be the only way Reid will let someone else play) and we can see what they have to offer, I see no problem with that.

[Diomedes]

If he's out, he's out.  No sense crying about it, I agree.  I value him higher than most other do though, so I hope he's alright.

[Diomedes]

Oddly enough, I don't base my opinions on what goes on on this board.

So when you said "Pinkston bashing isn't..." you weren't talking about Pink bashing generally--only about your own? 

Of course you don't base your opinion on this board.  But it is a fact that he was not widely hated in this forum until the overly publicized episodes last year.  Taking this board as a weathervane for fan opinion, I continue to disagree with you:  most Pink bashing is ignorant.

[rjs246]

Oddly enough, I don't base my opinions on what goes on on this board.

So when you said "Pinkston bashing isn't..." you weren't talking about Pink bashing generally--only about your own? 

Actually, yes. I was only talking about my own bashing. I try not to speak for others, but I guess I can see how you thought I was there.

[General_Failure]

About half of everything you find anywhere is going to be worse than the other half. Still, I'll deal with the anti-Pinkston bandwagoners as long as it means not everyone thinks every palyer we've got is super duper.

Now when we get to a situation where most everyone thinks every player sucks ...

[ice grillin you]

Right because seeing if G. Lew can be the #2 and having Reggie Brown getting time at the #3 spot is a bad thing in the big picture

yeah lets just mess around and see if an unproven player and a rookie can fill the  2 and 3 spots on a team thats supposed to win the superbowl

youre talking like the birds were 4-12 last year...sure why not just try some youngsters this year...see if it all works out

[MURP]

Until someone else gets a chance to be the #2 in this offense we will never know how productive Pinkston is or isnt.   Maybe Greg Lewis will show that Pinkston was a really valuable asset.  Maybe Greg Lewis will show that Pinkston isnt that good and any half decent WR could perform in this offense.

[hunt]

pinkston sucks

[rjs246]

Until someone else gets a chance to be the #2 in this offense we will never know how productive Pinkston is or isnt.   Maybe Greg Lewis will show that Pinkston was a really valuable asset.  Maybe Greg Lewis will show that Pinkston isnt that good and any half decent WR could perform in this offense.

Holy shtein! Someone gets it!

pinkston sucks

Holy shtein! Someone gets it!

[Diomedes]

Until someone else gets a chance to be the #2 in this offense we will never know how productive Pinkston is or isnt. Maybe Greg Lewis will show that Pinkston was a really valuable asset. Maybe Greg Lewis will show that Pinkston isnt that good and any half decent WR could perform in this offense.

Buddha speaks.  Of course you're right.  And if Pink is out, then we're about to find out.  I'd rather not be forced to learn it by circumstances like these however.

[Wingspan]

Oddly enough, I don't base my opinions on what goes on on this board.

So when you said "Pinkston bashing isn't..." you weren't talking about Pink bashing generally--only about your own? 

Of course you don't base your opinion on this board.  But it is a fact that he was not widely hated in this forum until the overly publicized episodes last year.  Taking this board as a weathervane for fan opinion, I continue to disagree with you:  most Pink bashing is ignorant.

NFCCG vs the Panthers was the last straw for me there.

then lost in the lights (LIAR)

then farging cramps in the superbowl. (DRINK SOME GODDAMN WATER!) christ, he should know by his size that he probably gets dehydrated taking a piss.

[MURP]

I'd rather not be forced to learn it by circumstances like these however.

not a gambler eh Dio? 

What if Greg Lewis is fargin amazing? 

[ice grillin you]

if greg lewis was so amazing do you not think reid and company would know this...and move him ahead of pinky on the depth chart

either way its just stupid to not care if pinky was out for the year...dont even know why we are discussing this

[MURP]

if greg lewis was so amazing do you not think reid and company would know this...and move him ahead of pinky on the depth chart

your talking about a coach who STARTED JAMES THRASH at #1 for years.    I think losing Pink hurts the team right now (if in fact he is out), but im not going to pretend there isnt a possible positive outcome from it.