Is McNabb too sensitive?

[Zanshin]

I wonder if all of this has made McNabb think differently about Philly. He's always had a bug up his ass and never really seemed to embrace the city...but now that he's seen nothing but failure outside of the city, does he look back on it more fondly? Has to be a slap of reality that the Eagles had just as much success without him.

[Sgt PSN]

I suppose he might if  you define success as not winning a SB. In which case, the Eagles have enjoyed the same level of success with every QB over the last 45 years.

[Zanshin]

Well, that's what I mean. Good, but not good enough. Playoff good...not SB-winning good; exactly like his time here.

[Rome]

There is no way the wristband story is accurate.

I mean, no one could be that bitchmade and still make it for ten years in the NFL.

[ice grillin you]

Well, that's what I mean. Good, but not good enough. Playoff good...not SB-winning good; exactly like his time here.

he made a superbowl so in his mind hes still the winner...shtein the eagles havent won a playoff game without him

[Zanshin]

He also almost single-handedly lost that Superbowl.

[ice grillin you]

he did single handedly lose it but i thought you were wondering how mcnabb compares philly with and without him...you said its the same...playoff good but not good enough...im saying mcnabb would say his time was way better...four nfc champs and a superbowl appearance

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Well, that's what I mean. Good, but not good enough. Playoff good...not SB-winning good; exactly like his time here.

he made a superbowl so in his mind hes still the winner...shtein the eagles havent won a playoff game without him

Yes, in the one season they played without him, they did not win a playoff game. Correct!

[ice grillin you]

yeah mcnabb definitely wouldnt think that way because hes never salty doent have a long memory and absolutely doesnt hold grudges

[phattymatty]

all it takes is a quick look at that air guitar video and all the love i've ever had for the guy goes right out the window.  that was the exact moment i started disliking him.

[Eagles_Legendz]

i still love vick's reaction in the background.  he may not have seen him before he put his head down and started shaking it, but i like to pretend that he did.

[ice grillin you]

for a hot second during that episode my five hate turned to pity

[Rome]

all it takes is a quick look at that air guitar video and all the love i've ever had for the guy goes right out the window.  that was the exact moment i started disliking him.

This.

[Sgt PSN]

Well, that's what I mean. Good, but not good enough. Playoff good...not SB-winning good; exactly like his time here.

he made a superbowl so in his mind hes still the winner...shtein the eagles havent won a playoff game without him

Jeff Garcia says Hi. 

[shorebird]

all it takes is a quick look at that air guitar video and all the love i've ever had for the guy goes right out the window.  that was the exact moment i started disliking him.

This.

Made me wanna' puke.