Michael Vick, Philadelphia Eagle

[General_Failure]

Adios, Ron.

[Tomahawk]

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2012/12/08/vick-could-land-in-buffalo-next-season/

Or do the Eagles re-work his deal and keep him here?

Why keep him? He's always been terrible, 2010 was an anomaly.

Still, he's as good or better than plenty of current starting quarterbacks

Plenty? I don't think so.

[ice grillin you]

hes not a better quarterback than anyone....he might be a better player than a few quarterbacks

[Diomedes]

thinking just about three teams...

who would you rather have:

Sanchez
Tebow
Cassell
Quinn
Kolb
Skelton

or


Vick


The answer is Vick, and not just because he's a better football player, but because he's a better quarterback than any of these.

[ice grillin you]

no he isnt

but to answer the question id rather have any of them over vick except tebow but hes not a starter now and has no chance of being one next year

[General_Failure]

I don't think I'd take Sanchez over Vick either, but when you're that far down the list of quarterbacks you're just trying to figure out how dry the turds are.

[MDS]

the difference between those guys and vick is vick cant not suck

sanchez can if you ask him hand the ball off, throw it away and hit short routes and check downs. vick will feel the wind and fumble or get scared from pressure and run and fumble. then hell get another concussion.

hes probably the worst player in football all things considered. him or carson palmer, actually.

[ice grillin you]

exactly....a good coach could coax some good things out of sanchez...rex ryan could be the worst possible coach a qb could ever have....where as vick could have an offensive genius behind him and would still suck...he doesnt have a single skill that lends itself to qb'ing at the professional level

[MDS]

they sort of tried to do that this year with vick. a few games in they stopped extending the field...everything was short and simple. vick got even worse.

when he was at his athletic peek he was a good nfl qb. that 1 year with the eagles he was awesome for a bunch of games, but it really tailed off at the end (giants comeback was a mirage). since then hes been dreadful.

its tough for people to get past what happened in 2006 but it cant be anymore clear now, in 2012---MICHAEL VICK SUCKS!!

[ice grillin you]

when he was at his athletic peek he was a good nfl qb.

first of all his athletic peek was in atlanta when he won at lambeau....secondly you are confusing good athlete with good qb....he has always been a terrible qb...the fact that andy reid thought he had the midas touch and could somehow transform him into a nfl qb is in a nutshell everything thats wrong with the franchise

jesus are you making me sick on purpose???

[MDS]

we agree with each other

why are you creating an argument.

[ice grillin you]

i dont wanna argue but i get really upset when people say he was ever a good qb

[MDS]

there was a point in atlanta when he was not among the worst qbs in the league

true or false

[ice grillin you]

false....

unless you worked for espn

[MDS]

andrew walter
chazz frye
joey harrington
bruce gradkowski
rex grossman
matt leinart
alex smith pre harbaugh
david carr
jake delhomme
jp losman

would you rather have vick or any of those guys