Michael Vick, Philadelphia Eagle

[reese125]

just for arguments sake--where are you putting elway that makes his statement so far fetched?

[rjs246]

Not in the top two and definitely not so firmly entrenched in the top two that you could just throw his name out as an obvious choice.

[SunMo]

Montana, Elway, Brady, Manning, Marino

[Eagles_Legendz]

Looks about right to me, though I think by the time they're done, Brady and Manning will be with Montana 1/2/3 personally.

[Rome]

A quarterback with a career completion percentage under 60% probably shouldn't make the top 5.

[reese125]

To me...after Montana, they are all debatable.

[ice grillin you]

steve young was better than montana

[reese125]

I know, and I have a beach house in Nebraska.

[ice grillin you]

he had the accuracy of montana coud run like vick and had jeff georges arm...i never saw a better qb than him

[General_Failure]

And when he was done playing, he had the brain of a toddler. Or Todd.

[reese125]

if you want to judge a qb by his post season performance--there was none better than joe montana. thats a trump in my book.

[General_Failure]

Tom Brady's certainly catching up.

[lurking wierdo]

Steve Young has to be in that group. And the correct actor to play MV is Pootie Tang.

[shorebird]

It has not. And this is Eagles fans saying it too.

"I'm not a fan, I hate him and will never forgive him...no matter how good he is...he's no better than a pedophile and he's a murderer."

I can't help but laugh at the stupidity of these kinds of people. Murder? No. Animal cruelty, hell yes, but you don't murder dogs. If your gonna' hate, at least get the shtein right.

I ain't even commentin' on the "pedophile" crap.

[Eagaholic]

Unitas undoubtedly should be top 3