Kevin Kolb, Philadelphia Eagle

[Rome]

unless the tub of bacon fat changes his offensive philosophy it wouldn't matter if joe montana in his prime was the quarterback.

you'd think after 11 years of this that simple fact would be self-evident.

alas...

[ice grillin you]

unless the tub of bacon fat changes his offensive philosophy it wouldn't matter if joe montana in his prime was the quarterback.

you'd think after 11 years of this that simple fact would be self-evident.

alas...

this couldnt be more wrong...well i wouldnt say wrong but saying this is as dumb as pg saying cobb will automatically stink

his offense could easily win a superbowl in this league...and i hate the guy

[PhillyGirl]

Where did I say he will automatically stink?

I don't have faith that he will win the Eagles a Super Bowl.

[Rome]

please show me an offense that throws the ball 60 percent of the time and doesn't run the ball effectively that has won a super bowl.

i'll wait...

[ice grillin you]

i dont feel like doing a search but you have killed him as a qb dozens maybe hundreds of times

and now your big proclamation is that he wont win what less than 30 qb's that have ever played in the league have won

pretty ballsy there

[PhillyGirl]

as usual, you're missing my point.

The goal of a football team is to draft/get a QB that will help your team (lead them) to win a SB.

I do not have the faith in Kolb that he is that guy.

[MDS]

why not

is there evidence or is this in your gut and your goin at this bush style?

[General_Failure]

as usual, you're missing my point.

The goal of a football team is to draft/get a QB that will help your team (lead them) to win a SB.

That's what the goal should be. In reality, the goal of this football team is to sell tickets and jerseys by being good enough to make the playoffs consistently. You know this.

[ice grillin you]

please show me an offense that throws the ball 60 percent of the time and doesn't run the ball effectively that has won a super bowl.

i'll wait...

for one eagles dont throw it 60% of the time...they go 58% of the time

and i dont know if any teams have thrown for 58 and won it all...i doubt it...but i know for a fact that more than one have gone 55 plus and won it

the league is different now...its not the 70's or 80's or even 90's...its an all pass league...and the eagles can def win a title at their run pass ratio...the real question is can a coach who cant in game adjust and is terrible at clock management win a superbowl

in the end you reid with a new qb deserves a chance to be judged just as mcnabb with a new coach deserves the same

but to bring up the old tired run pass ratio thing is being short minded imo

[PhillyGirl]

why not

is there evidence or is this in your gut and your goin at this bush style?

Its my feeling on it. You don't have to agree, its just how I feel.

Why is it okay for you all to have such strong opinions on players but the second I do, its crucified?

[MDS]

what you feel is how you feel that isnt it

its why

if its a random feeling based on nothing then i hate to say it, but thats a bushian method.

if youve got some evidence or some facts or a basis, then by all means, share it

[ice grillin you]

picking out a random first time starter in the nfl and saying you dont think he will win a superbowl is not a feeling

i dont think brad edwards can ever win a superbowl

i dont think sam bradford can win a superbowl

i dont think trent dilfer can win a superbowl

i dont think matt cassel can win a superbowl

i dont think kurt warner can win a superbowl

i dont think _______________ can win a superbowl


thats not a feeling thats making an almost lock solid bet

less than 1% of the qb's to ever play in the league have won a superbowl

[Rome]

do you have multiple personalities?

[ice grillin you]

not tonight

[Munson]

I'm just glad that we're all positioning ourselves squarely on the middle of the fence so we can all claim to look smart after the fact.

Everyone but PG, that is.

no one is in the middle...99% of people havent made a judgement yet...being in the middle is going both ways...

enter munson: if the eagles win with cobb hes joe montana and would win with any offense...if the eagles lose with cobb...its andy and i told you so...i dont expect actual thought from him because his brain neutrons dont fire...but he doesnt care about anything except making mcnabb innocent in the last 11 years...doesnt matter what happens in dc or philly for the next 100 years donovan would have won with a different coach and thats that

agree on pg....as inept as her thinking is at least she standing her ground...she has barely any evidence whatsoever to think this way but shes sticking to it and if nothing else that honorable

If the eagles win the SB with Kolb, then either Kolb is infinitely better than any of us could have ever hoped, or Andy Reid balanced out the offense. If Kolb is somewhere on McNabb's level, and the offense remains the same, we're looking at more 2nd round playoff exits and lost NFC Championship games.  Yay!

I know you have a really hard time reading, but no one is making McNabb out to be "innocent"...what the intelligent people who have the ability of cognitive thought have been saying is that all the dog piling on McNabb like it was mostly his fault is ridiculous and retarded. Of course he deserves some of the blame for the choke jobs, but he certainly isn't the only one to blame. McNabb was(is?) good enough to win with a competent coach on a good team. The dude's weakness is his accuracy and yet you insist at throwing at a 60% clip...an NFL coach who plans on keeping that guy around for 11 years should have been smart enough to take notice and adjust the offense accordingly.