Can We All Finally Agree Donovan Needs To Burn In Hell (even you phreak)

[Sgt PSN]

i've been wondering how long it would take before someone finally started making any sense. 

[PhillyPhanInDC]

Mike Schmidt is one of the greatest baseball players in the history of the game, there's nobody on this team that will ever surpass him.  moron.

Mike Schmidt is an icehole, so that knocks him down a peg. Pelle Lindbergh, Steve Carlton, Wilt, Reggie, Randall all come way ahead of BHop in my opinion.

[SunMo]

lol at pelle lindbergh...dude played for 15 minutes and he's ahead of Bhop for greatest philly athlete? 

[Sgt PSN]

he was the first to rock the goalie mask, right?  clearly that's a testament to his athletic superiority. 

btw....schmidt is an ass from almost all accounts, but still doesn't make any of his 548 homers any less awesome. 

[PhillyPhanInDC]

lol at pelle lindbergh...dude played for 15 minutes and he's ahead of Bhop for greatest philly athlete?  

In terms of accomplishments on the field, not ahead of BHop, in terms of being a Philly sports legend and being revered by the fanbase, absolutely.

[MDS]

Lol @ carlton

He's not a crazy racist or nothing

[PhillyPhreak54]

Ricky Jordan > Bernard Hopkins

[Sgt PSN]

has any phillie since jordan homered in their first ml at bat? 

[PhillyPhreak54]

Hmmmmm...good question, Sarge.

I would think yeah...PAGING BIG ED, PAGING BIG ED!!

[Munson]

Mike Schmidt is one of the greatest baseball players in the history of the game, there's nobody on this team that will ever surpass him.  moron.

You do realize that Chase Utley is already talked about like he's one of the best ever? Never on here obviously because he's not black, but all the talking heads on ESPN/Fox/whathaveyou. Not that they're the smartest guys in the world, but I'll take a former MLB players opinion on another MLB baseball player over anyone here.

[Munson]

has any phillie since jordan homered in their first ml at bat? 

I know Mayberry Jr. did it in his first game this past year, but I don't remember if it was his first or 2nd at bat.

[phillymic2000]

Bhop is the man, its a debate but he is without a doubt top 5 all time in philly

[SunMo]

You do realize that Chase Utley is already talked about like he's one of the best ever? Never on here obviously because he's not black, but all the talking heads on ESPN/Fox/whathaveyou. Not that they're the smartest guys in the world, but I'll take a former MLB players opinion on another MLB baseball player over anyone here.

lol...WHAT??

i have never heard anybody refer to Chase Utley as one of the greatest players ever.  Maybe he can be the best second basemen ever, but that's even a huge stretch.

how you think Chase Utely is a better Philly athlete than Mike Schmidt is farging mind numbing.  i know you're like 17 and you have no clue about the history of the city's teams prior to your mom getting raped by your grandad and having you...but still, have some sense of history about your teams so you don't sound like such a flapping douchebag.

[rjs246]

I literally had no idea that douchebags could flap. You learn something new every day.

[reese125]

Maybe he can be the best second basemen ever, but that's even a huge stretch.

not a huge stretch at all