Can We All Finally Agree Donovan Needs To Burn In Hell (even you phreak)

[hbionic]

your homerism for him knows no bounds. you are literally the only person on earth besides wilma that liked his air guitar and plexiglass hump. nothing is his fault, its always someone else. but i have to admit, he probably has a nice dong.

I feel bad for Vick. He has to put up with McNabb being such a douche bag. He must have known it was going to be over before it started...as did I.

A black man doing an air guitar should automatically trigger an implosion of self. Same thing when a white man tries to beat box.

[Munson]

I think it all boils down to whether one believes ReidCo can instantly and regularly win 10 games a season without McNabb. And frankly that test is coming one day soon regardless.

Would a couple or three seasons of close but no cigar be OK using Cobbsy? For me yep, as I'm at the point where that is preferable to stasis. I believe a new QB will force a change to ReidCos game plan. To me this is what is needed. Reid ain't going nowhere. Losing McNabb brings some trepidation, but it needs to be done and the cowpuke ass raping brings it sooner IMO.

Too bad it won't be in 2010.

That is the only hope there is....that not having McNabb in there will force Reid to be more balanced, as he has tended to be when McNabb has been hurt.

I have absolutely no faith in Kolb dropping back 40 times a game consistently.

[Drunkmasterflex]

Domo was just on DNL and he thinks that McNabb is gone this offseason via trade.  Him and Baldy believe they will go with Kolb.  Man I hope it is true.  Not that anyone knows what Kolb is but we know what McNabb isn't. 

[Sgt PSN]

i was afraid this would happen.....after 3 or 4 solid days of ripping mcnabb and wanting him jettisoned into football obscurity, the pain from last week's game is beginning to go away and i find myself wanting to believe in mcnabb again.  why can't i just let him go?

maybe it's because i've seen this before with cunningham.  randall was being ridiculed by the fans and media for the eagles post season failures just as much as mcnabb is now.  there were the "ran-doll" chants during his last few years in philly and just an overwhelming desire to get him away from the eagles. 

then he left and a few years later, resurfaced with minny and all of a sudden i hear eagle fans cursing the team for letting him go.  and now-a-days you will never ever ever hear a single eagles fan say anything bad about randall cunningham. 

so i guess i know that that is exactly what's going to happen with mcnabb.  if he gets run out of town people will be happy.  but 10 years from now you won't be able to mention mcnabb's name without hearing "oh man, mcnabb was the shtein back in the day." 

[Munson]

Everyone with half a brain knows this team is going to miss McNabb when he's gone.

It's the hate filled fools on here that want to blame everything on him that think him being gone will somehow turn Reid into a super bowl winning coach.


I can promise you that won't be with Kevin Kolb throwing 65% of the time. If they get lucky and land a better QB, or if Reid balances out the play calling, then maybe.

[Sgt PSN]

god you're dumb.  you're agreeing with me and yet i read your post and think that you are literally the dumbest person alive.  you really are a special mother farger. 

[shorebird]

Hahaha! Now McNabb is fat, slow, and everything that was wrong with the offense last week was his fault. Geez.

[Sgt PSN]

your homerism for him knows no bounds. you are literally the only person on earth besides wilma that liked his air guitar and plexiglass hump. nothing is his fault, its always someone else. but i have to admit, he probably has a nice dong.

I feel bad for Vick. He has to put up with McNabb being such a douche bag. He must have known it was going to be over before it started...as did I.

A black man doing an air guitar should automatically trigger an implosion of self. Same thing when a white man tries to beat box.

or when a mexican tries to use birth control

[JackStraw]

Randall had some nice moments and a better punter than rugby-boy, but after that Dallas playoff loss as the unprepared back-up to rodneypeetecantbebeat he attained instant fagdom and remains to this day a tile-laying-non-HOF'ing fag.

And again, all at the hand of Dallas whose losses hold a special place in my left descending colon.

[Munson]

god you're dumb.  you're agreeing with me and yet i read your post and think that you are literally the dumbest person alive.  you really are a special mother farger. 

I love when people hate to try and blend in with the group.


I'm one of the few posting rationally around here. Your post about Cunningham was spot on. So is mine. Get over it.

[JackStraw]

mine was truer

[Drunkmasterflex]

Honestly, if Reid was leaving I would be fine with McNabb staying.  The thing is one of them has to go.  I have been a big McNabb supporter throughout his career, but the time has come to move on. 

People can defend McNabb all they want, the thing is when the game is big and you only have a small window to make plays....he doesn't.  No one knows what Kolb is yet, he could be Aaron Rodgers he could be Brian Griese. 

I can tell you this as long as Reid and McNabb are together this team won't win. 

[Sgt PSN]

I'm one of the few posting rationally around here.

lol

Your post about Cunningham was spot on.

i know it was.  otherwise i wouldn't have said it.  not sure how you can be in agreement with me though since you were like 4 the last time randall even suited up for the eagles, much less when he was in his prime with them.  watching old game tape in the rape basement, are we? 

So is mine.

your post was anything but spot on, especially this part: 

It's the hate filled fools on here that want to blame everything on him that think him being gone will somehow turn Reid into a super bowl winning coach.

i have not seen a single person here say that they think reid is going to win a super bowl without mcnabb.  if such a post does exist, please direct me to the author so i can skullfarg him/her.

I can promise you that won't be with Kevin Kolb throwing 65% of the time. If they get lucky and land a better QB, or if Reid balances out the play calling, then maybe.

so what you're saying is that with a better qb and more balanced playcalling, the eagles might win a super bowl.  thanks for the insiders info, sport. 

Get over it.

get dead. 

[NC_Eagle]

http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/blog/shutdown_corner/post/Is-it-time-for-the-Eagles-to-rid-themselves-of-D?urn=nfl,213341

Is it time for the Eagles to rid themselves of Donovan McNabb?

I don't believe so, but you know what it is time for? Large groups of fans in Philadelphia to lose their minds, blame every Eagles failing on Donovan McNabb(notes), and call for him to be replaced, banished and beaten.

It feels a little different this year, because all of the discussion is moot -- head coach Andy Reid will be back, and he's already said that he wants McNabb back with him. It's a done deal. Of course, none of this stops all the discussing, shouting and complaining.

It feels like I say it every year, but my opinion on the staying or going of Donovan McNabb is this: When you have a better option, Eagles, then maybe you should think about it. Until that moment comes, however, you should probably be happy with the quarterback you have, who is better than the starting quarterbacks on most other NFL teams.

The NFL is not a league where you can succeed without a quality quarterback. With McNabb, you have someone you know is going to give you a quarterback rating of about 90, every year. That's pretty good. It's the kind of thing that allows you to, I don't know, win 10+ games a year, seven out of 10 years.

What plan do you have that could give you a non-McNabb quarterback next season who will also have a rating around 90? Is it Kevin Kolb(notes)? I guess there's an outside chance of that, but I wouldn't bet on it. It is Michael Vick(notes). Ha. No, it's not Michael Vick.

Is it someone you're going to draft? No, at least not right away. If you're willing to wait three years or so for the guy to develop into an upper-level NFL quarterback (and take the 50-50 shot that he'll turn into Rick Mirer), then hey, enjoy rebuilding. Is it someone in free agency? No, unless you like the idea of someone like Jeff Garcia(notes) or Daunte Culpepper(notes) captaining your franchise.

We don't even need to get into the discussion of how good or bad Donovan McNabb might be. There's no better option, and that's just the way it is. Your can either stick with McNabb, or rebuild and miss the playoffs for the next few years. There's no third way to go.

[Eagles_Legendz]

http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/blog/shutdown_corner/post/Is-it-time-for-the-Eagles-to-rid-themselves-of-D?urn=nfl,213341

Is it time for the Eagles to rid themselves of Donovan McNabb?

I don't believe so, but you know what it is time for? Large groups of fans in Philadelphia to lose their minds, blame every Eagles failing on Donovan McNabb(notes), and call for him to be replaced, banished and beaten.

It feels a little different this year, because all of the discussion is moot -- head coach Andy Reid will be back, and he's already said that he wants McNabb back with him. It's a done deal. Of course, none of this stops all the discussing, shouting and complaining.

It feels like I say it every year, but my opinion on the staying or going of Donovan McNabb is this: When you have a better option, Eagles, then maybe you should think about it. Until that moment comes, however, you should probably be happy with the quarterback you have, who is better than the starting quarterbacks on most other NFL teams.

The NFL is not a league where you can succeed without a quality quarterback. With McNabb, you have someone you know is going to give you a quarterback rating of about 90, every year. That's pretty good. It's the kind of thing that allows you to, I don't know, win 10+ games a year, seven out of 10 years.

What plan do you have that could give you a non-McNabb quarterback next season who will also have a rating around 90? Is it Kevin Kolb(notes)? I guess there's an outside chance of that, but I wouldn't bet on it. It is Michael Vick(notes). Ha. No, it's not Michael Vick.

Is it someone you're going to draft? No, at least not right away. If you're willing to wait three years or so for the guy to develop into an upper-level NFL quarterback (and take the 50-50 shot that he'll turn into Rick Mirer), then hey, enjoy rebuilding. Is it someone in free agency? No, unless you like the idea of someone like Jeff Garcia(notes) or Daunte Culpepper(notes) captaining your franchise.

We don't even need to get into the discussion of how good or bad Donovan McNabb might be. There's no better option, and that's just the way it is. Your can either stick with McNabb, or rebuild and miss the playoffs for the next few years. There's no third way to go.

Whoever wrote this is a farging moron.  What did you expect Reid to say?  "Yeah, I think we'll be shopping McNabb, let you know how that works out after I get off the phone with a few teams"?  And there's no reason to speculate on who the Eagles would replace him with.  Daunte Culpepper or Jeff Garcia?  The replacement is already on the roster.  Whether Kolb works or not is yet to be seen.  We may not know what Kolb is, but as DMF said, we know what McNabb isn't.  After 10 seasons, that's good enough for me.