It's swell to dream.....say Reid gets canned....

[henchmanUK]

Man, I would love Jacobs and Boss on our team.

I'll pass on Jacobs.  He's good now, very good.  But unless he's special in a hall of fame sort of way, he'll be unremarkable in 3 years.  He's too big.  It's too easy for any two bit defensive player to get a solid hit on him.  He'll break down and be gone sooner than later.

Unless he's special, of course.  

I can't believe anyone would say that after seeing him destroy Laron Landry. He doesn't get hit by defensive players, especially two bit ones. He hits them.

He already looks special.

I agree. On pitchouts, where the first man he meets is an OLB or corner he is brutal. But Boss is awesome. The Giants were so much better last year after Shockey got injured. I'd vote him for Pro Bowl.

[shorebird]

[General_Failure]

Reid has defensive ends playing tackle, offensive tackles playing guard, speed rushing ends playing linebacker, an Aussie Rules Footballer punting and a defensive tackle playing fullback.

That punter is probably a better tackler than any of the linebackers. A better punter, too.

[henchmanUK]

Reid has defensive ends playing tackle, offensive tackles playing guard, speed rushing ends playing linebacker, an Aussie Rules Footballer punting and a defensive tackle playing fullback.

That punter is probably a better tackler than any of the linebackers. A better punter, too.

Strweth, Sav should be MVP of this team, cobber. Being an Aussie Rules player didn't hurt Darren Bennett.

[stalker]

Coughlin sucked til last year.

I disagree. He did a pretty good job with Jacksonville. He just needed to get rid of whiny bitches like Tiki and Shockey to make it work.

If you say he did a pretty good job in Jacksonville, how can you think Reid sucks here?

[henchmanUK]

Coughlin sucked til last year.

I disagree. He did a pretty good job with Jacksonville. He just needed to get rid of whiny bitches like Tiki and Shockey to make it work.

If you say he did a pretty good job in Jacksonville, how can you think Reid sucks here?

It's a fair point. Maybe Reid will do what Coughlin did, and become a head coach only again and that will get him over the hump.

[The BIGSTUD]

Why did we even sign Kyle Eckel if we aren't going to use him?

[General_Failure]

In case Klecko gets hurt, silly.

[ice grillin you]

lololol...the coach and rb of the team that just a. ran over the eagles and b. won the superbowl both suck

got it

[rjs246]

Coughlin sucked til last year.

I disagree. He did a pretty good job with Jacksonville. He just needed to get rid of whiny bitches like Tiki and Shockey to make it work.

If you say he did a pretty good job in Jacksonville, how can you think Reid sucks here?

Their in-game coaching styles could not be any different.

The only similarities they share are 1. They're stubborn and not 'players coaches' and 2. In their first coaching stints they didn't win a championship.

Other than that they are nothing alike.

[ice grillin you]

andy reid = good person and horrible coach

tom coughlin = horrible person and good coach

[rjs246]

Ha. Nice.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Andy's not even a good person, actually.

[MDS]

a good person wouldnt have brit reid as a son

[stalker]

andy reid = good person and horrible coach

tom coughlin = horrible person and good coach

No, the point is that if the only way to judge how good of a coach someone is is by counting Superbowls they won, then until 2008 Coughlin=Reid.

And along that same line of logic,

Brian Billick= Mike Holmgren = Tony Dungy = Dick Vermiel = Mike Ditka > Buddy Ryan = Marv Levy