The Sopranos

[The BIGSTUD]

They don't show Meadow come into the diner though. The actual shot is Tony's face looking up in part curiousness, part paranoia. Which is exactly what Tony is going to have to continue to go through the rest of his life as long as he is in the mafia.

[Seabiscuit36]

http://www.nj.com/columns/ledger/se...9770.xml&coll=1
Don't stop believing
Monday, June 11, 2007
BY ALAN SEPINWALL
The Star-Ledger
Who knew that the music of Journey could be used so ironically?

At the end of an otherwise satisfying "Sopranos" series finale, creator David Chase threw one final curveball at his audience. In his first episode as both writer and director since the series pilot, Chase sent Tony to a family dinner at Holsten's ice cream parlor in Bloomfield. Many previous seasons had ended on a Soprano family tableau -- A.J. even quoted something Tony said at Vesuvio back in the season one finale -- but this one was edited to seem far more ominous.

As the sounds of Steve Perry wailing on "Don't Stop Believing" filled the soundtrack, Tony kept eyeing the door and the other patrons as first Carmela, then A.J. arrived, while we spent an interminable amount of time watching Meadow double park. The camera kept focusing on a shady-looking character at the bar with more than a passing resemblance to the late Eugene Pontecorvo (down to the Member's Only jacket) who was studying Tony, but then his advance on Tony turned out to be a trip to the men's room. Meadow finally parked, dashed towards Holsten's, the camera cut back to Tony in close-up looking at something, Perry sang the words "Don't stop," and...

... nothing. No hint of whether Tony was looking at Meadow or something else entirely (perhaps the feds coming to arrest him after Carlo Gervasi apparently flipped), no music of any kind, just a fast cut to black and then the closing credits playing out in complete silence.

Whether you were waiting for one of the more popular predicted endings -- Tony in Witness Protection, Tony killed by Phil's guys, Furio and/or the Russian coming back for revenge, what have you -- or just for an ending, period, chances are that cut-to-black had you pulling a William Shatner in "Wrath of Khan," pointing your face at the heavens and bellowing, "CHAAAAASE!!"

And yet the finale, both the first 55 minutes of it and that sadistic last scene, fit perfectly with everything Chase has done on this show before.

Did we get the violent fireworks of last week? Absolutely not, as the only deaths of the hour were Phil Leotardo (gunned down at a gas station, then, in a gruesome indignity, his skull crushed post-mortem by his rolling car), and A.J.'s SUV (which caught fire while idling near a pile of leaves). But that's been the pattern of every season: the major action goes in the penultimate episode, while the finale is saved for quiet reflection and the odd whacking or two.

So Tony and Butchie DeConcini negotiated a peace treaty -- with the tacit understanding that Tony's guys could eliminate the out-of-control Phil -- a third of the way through the episode, and the bulk of the hour focused on Tony's lower-case family.

Janice faced life without Bacala (and a lifetime of torment for Bobby's kids), and once again invoked the name and memory of Livia Soprano, going about in pity for herself. Janice and Tony each visited Junior in the run-down state facility he was banished to when his cash ran out, but Corrado didn't recognize them.

Meadow planned her wedding to Patrick Parisi and badly wounded Tony (without realizing it) by telling him that she decided to quit med school and become a lawyer because of her relationship to him.

And in the episode's centerpiece -- and the origin of its title, "Made in America" -- A.J. continued his political awakening, only to have Tony and Carmela seduce him back into the same comfortably numb existence he used to have.

When some of the guests at Bacala's wake started discussing "American Idol" and "Dreamgirls," A.J. harangued them for focusing on entertainment fluff.

"The world. Don't you see it?" he complained, then later said, "It's like America. This is still where people come to make it. It's a beautiful idea. And then what do they get? Bling and come-ons for (stuff) they don't need and can't afford?" He talked of enlisting in the Army, though he wavered on whether it was to make the world a better place or just to get a job as Donald Trump's personal chopper pilot.

Yet by episode's end, A.J. had abandoned his newfound morality in favor of a shiny BMW, a job as the "development executive" for Little Carmine's movie company and his parents' promise of his own nightclub to follow.

From the start, Chase has used "The Sopranos" as an indictment of modern American values and how, time after time, we all sacrifice principle in favor of self-interest. Maybe A.J. had achieved enlightenment or maybe not. But Tony and Carmela couldn't have their little boy risking his own life in the military (they wanted him to get the discipline without the risk), so they anesthetized him back into the materialistic lifestyle they understand so well. This is what America makes today, Chase seemed to be saying: permissive, selfish parents and kids who mimic them.

Back to that final scene. Without it, we have a completely reasonable finale, one that provides closure on enough plot threads (the war with New York ends, Paulie is promoted to the captaincy of the Family's lucrative construction business, A.J. finds new direction, etc.) that the few left open (notably whether Carlo flipped and what that means, legally, for Tony) don't particularly sting. It's the "life goes on" ending I'd been speculating on for months.

But then, but then, but then ... then Chase has to do what he loves to do more than any other man in show business: completely mess with his viewers' expectations (and their heads). I don't consider it a cliffhanger, something to set up a movie, as I doubt there will ever be a movie (and if there is, it'll be set in the past). He did it because he hates the conventions of TV series narrative in general, and putting a bow on things in particular.

That's why the Russian never came back, why the Melfi rape plotline was dismissed with a single word ("No"), why none of the FBI's previous rats ever amounted to anything, etc. He's convinced the audience doesn't need to be spoon-fed, to the point where he might go for a non-ending like this, something so jarring, so abrupt and so filled with misdirection (my guess is there was no danger at all, that Tony was simply watching Meadow's entrance) that it might come across like an insult to the audience who have stuck with the show through thick and thin.

Somehow, though, it feels like the perfect final note. Why wouldn't a show that's taken such pleasure in rewriting the rules of storytelling -- from making a sociopathic thug its hero on down -- go out in the least conventional way possible? It may be maddening, but it's what David Chase does.

Some other thoughts on "Made in America":

A theory proposed by a reader of the NJ.com Sopranos blog using the handle Lorbnash: the nine episodes of this season have represented the nine circles of Hell from Dante's "The Divine Comedy." The fourth circle, for instance, is for the greedy and the miserly; the fourth episode was Tony and Hesh's gambling showdown. The seventh circle is where the suicides go; A.J. took his dip in the family pool in episode seven. The ninth circle is for the traitors, and Butchie implicitly betrayed Phil. (For added fun, reader Joe Adler pointed out the similarities between the Eugene Delacroix painting "The Barque of Dante" and the Annie Leibovitz promotional image on the season five DVD set. Google them both if you want your mind blown.)

Lots of surrogates and callbacks throughout. Junior confuses Janice and Livia (and Janice and Nica). Tony uses A.J.'s shrink (a leggy, coolly professional woman in the Lorraine Bracco mode) as a Melfi stand-in. A.J. quotes Livia's "Always with the drama," and later Tony's line from the Season One finale. Paulie believes the cat from the safehouse has some supernatural connection to Christopher and also notes the bad history of the captains in charge of Jersey construction (though he left out Jimmy "The Rat" Altieri).

Another "Whatever happened to Gary Cooper?" moment: the tour bus drives through Little Italy while the guide explains how the thriving neighborhood is now essentially a single block of shops and cafes -- so tiny that, when Butchie gets too wrapped up in a phone call to Phil, he wanders out of Little Italy altogether.

Who knew Agent Harris had such a dark side? He's conducting an affair with his counterpart at the Brooklyn field office, and he's actively rooting for Tony to take out Phil.

Finally, thanks for all the questions, theories and compliments you've sent me over the years as I've written about this show. "The Sopranos" is over, but our coverage of it has a few days to go -- and my work as the Star-Ledger's TV critic has a lot longer than that. The "Sopranos" blog (blog.nj.com/alltv/) will feature at least two reader mailbags as the week moves along, as there's still much to discuss. This has been fun.

[MDS]

He hit it on the nose. But I love how after all this time, so many people assumed they would get the simple "lives or dies" ending.

[ice grillin you]

i loved it...didnt cater to the mtv generation and wrap everything up in a nice neat little bow...the show basically ended the way it began...tony still being haunted by his mother...the scene where he goes to talk about aj's problems and ends up finding a new therapist was brilliant...still living the life of the gangsta having to sleep with one eye open...still having the same family problems we all have...still ice cold (see his reactions to sil and bobbys deaths)

i think it very well may have been the best series finale ever and def made up for much of the crap that has been the last two seasons...i loved how it didnt get to deep theres no need to overanalyze it...the guy didnt kill tony romey...like sun said it was to show how tony must continue to live his life in fear...notice every single time he heard the bell on the door of the restuarant he quickly looked up...not see if it was one of his family members but to see if the worng person was comign thru the door

the episode was basically a capsule of what his life has always been and what its always gonna be...imo it was perfect

what i thought was most brilliant about it was that last night was a finale yet it easily could have served as the pilot...the show came full circle

[Susquehanna Birder]

I really didn't mind the way it ended, other than the specific point where it did. The cut-to-black thing was really odd, and I'm sure it made plenty of people wonder what the hell happened to their TV.

[Seabiscuit36]

I'm with IGY, i love the ending.  Chase doesnt like the whole MTV Generation as IGY said.  Loved the song selection.  The only thing i thought was really rushed was Phil dying, i guess i wanted something with a buildup like Bobby.  The fact that Phil basically got "Decapitated" was satisfying considering his use of teh word 2 episodes before. 

[Zanshin]

Count me as being pretty ambivilant about it.  Which, I sure, is shocking.

[Susquehanna Birder]

I laughed at the one FBI agent telling the other that Phil got "popped."

[PhillyPhreak54]

I liked when Paulie was fixin to take a swat at the cat with the broom and the tried to pretend like he was sweeping when Tony walked in

[MURP]

at first I thougth WTF, but after thinking about it from different angles I think the ending was great.  That last scene in the diner was super intense. 

[SunMo]

That last scene in the diner was super intense. 

yeah it was, i think we were supposed to feel like Tony feels all of the time

[Seabiscuit36]

Meadow taking 20 trys to park the car was so intense   

[SunMo]

that belongs in this thread and the woman thread

[SunMo]

an interesting theory was presented in a chat on NJ.com

imTN: where did the childless Phil Leotardo's two infant grandkids come from? How did Butchie get from Little Italy to Chinatown in 90 seconds? How did Patrick Parisi go from law student to practicing attorney on a big case? Who's this "George" guy who brokered the meeting with New York? Too much weirdness to be taken at face value.

JimTN: Too convenient to have a "new character" that has the clout to clean up the mess between Phil and Tony. The "George" figure is a complete figment of Tony's dreamworld imagination. Just like the new female therapist

JimTN: Only in Tony's dream world would Agent Harris cheer for the Jersy mob and refer to them as "we". Or Tony address Agent Harris as "my friend". A fantasy, guys. Start to finish. Reality descended with the cut to black, not the opening credits.

JimTN: The attorney had always lived in Tony's world vicariously, through his legal dealings with Tony. The cameras were an extension of that voyeurism. But then, he wasn't really in the Bing to begin with. And we've never seen monitors on the dressing rooms before in eight years. Why now? Cause it wasn't real. Dream.

[MDS]

How much was a dream and how much was real, then?