2006 Point & Laugh at the taterskins thread

[ice grillin you]

Dawkins beat Taylor in ever single defensive stat that is measured by the NFL, yet you call it meaningless

defensive stats in general are meaningless so yes thats what im calling it

[PhillyPhreak54]

In the thread on ES one of the geniuses said they should go out and trade for Dunta Robinson or Fabian Washington now.

Jesus Christ.

[MURP]

Dawkins beat Taylor in ever single defensive stat that is measured by the NFL, yet you call it meaningless

defensive stats in general are meaningless so yes thats what im calling it

yet stats that you made up to support your point are totally legit.  ha.

[ice grillin you]

my support is that ive seen both play and taylor is superior right now...doesnt mean that dawk isnt still a good player and wasnt at one time great but its taylor right now no question

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

my support is that ive seen both play and taylor is superior right now...doesnt mean that dawk isnt still a good player and wasnt at one time great but its taylor right now no question

Your sampling of Taylor, being that you only watch Eagles games, is too small to speak informedly about.

[SunMo]

taterskins | Springs under the knife
Tue, 15 Aug 2006 12:45:30 -0700

ESPNews reports Washington taterskins CB Shawn Springs (abdominal) had abdominal surgery and will miss three to four weeks of action

[Beermonkey]

my support is that ive seen both play and taylor is superior right now...doesnt mean that dawk isnt still a good player and wasnt at one time great but its taylor right now no question

Your sampling of Taylor, being that you only watch Eagles games, is too small to speak informedly about.

Mike Sellers totally ran over Dawkins last year on one play, thereby Dawkins get's run over more than Taylor. I can't see how you could think otherwise. 

[ice grillin you]

dawkins missed a lot of tackles last year....way to many to be considered an elite safety anymore

[Beermonkey]

taterskins | Springs under the knife
Tue, 15 Aug 2006 12:45:30 -0700

ESPNews reports Washington taterskins CB Shawn Springs (abdominal) had abdominal surgery and will miss three to four weeks of action

That injury will only make him a better player once he returns. Just like that kid in "Rookie of the Year".

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

dawkins missed a lot of tackles last year....way to many to be considered an elite safety anymore

How could you possibly know how many tackles Taylor missed or didn't miss?

[General_Failure]

Taylor doesn't miss tackles. Receivers scare themselves so bad that they fall out of the way of the hit.

[ice grillin you]

Taylor doesn't miss tackles

beat me to it

[MURP]

its almost comical how you make blanket statements about players without even seeing a majority of the NFL actually play. 

[The BIGSTUD]

Taylor is invisible on the field. You wouldn't know he's out there because he isn't a playmaker.

[rjs246]

its almost comical how you make blanket statements about players without even seeing a majority of the NFL actually play.

Compared to how many other teams he watches, he sees the taterskins a ton. Two games a year?! That's more than the one Steelers game every four years that he watches yet, somehow, he knew that Randle El was a stud. Amazing! If he knows that much from one game per four years (plus the superbowl, presumably) imagine how much he know about the taterskins players! He sees them twice a year! Who needs more of a sample than that?