Would you trade Brian Westbrook for LaDainian Tomlinson?

[General_Failure]

Freddie's a 1337 HAX0R now. Learned a new skill now that his football days are behind him.

[Fan230]

Yep, I would

[stalker]

I think the overall difference between McNabb and Manning is pretty big, too. I guess that\'s my point.

I don\'t think anyone here would dispute the differences between Manning and McNabb.  However, I think it\'s a different story for runningbacks simply for the fact that if the runningback is good, he will do well just about anywhere and a QB needs to have the offensive system tailored specifically to him. 

Obviously, runningback productivity can increase or decrease based on the system he plays in but I think a good back will still be productive even when he\'s not playing in a system that is best suited for his particular style of play. 

I don\'t buy into the whole Manning/Mcnabb evaluation as a statement of football fact. I think alot has to be said for QB mobility.

[shorebird]

I'd like to know who voted 'NO'.

That being said, there are quite a few rb's I'd trade Bwest for, LT being the first.