Couple of Heckert tidbits from Reuben Frank

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Let me answer that for you, SD:  62nd overall.  No one here is contending that Robinson is the kind of prospect coming out of school that Antwaan Randle-El was.  I'm saying he could go as early as 100 or so... that's a far cry from 62.

[SD_Eagle5]

...and Randle-El was picked where in the draft?

2nd round I believe.

[SD_Eagle5]

Let me answer that for you, SD:  62nd overall.  No one here is contending that Robinson is the kind of prospect coming out of school that Antwaan Randle-El was.  I'm saying he could go as early as 100 or so... that's a far cry from 62.

1st day pick: Yay or nay?

I say nay.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Let me answer that for you, SD:  62nd overall.  No one here is contending that Robinson is the kind of prospect coming out of school that Antwaan Randle-El was.  I'm saying he could go as early as 100 or so... that's a far cry from 62.

1st day pick: Yay or nay?

I say nay.

Ahem:

I don't think he should go on day 1.  Certainly not.  But he could go anywhere on day 2, probably the 5th or 6th.

So, nay.

[Drunkmasterflex]

Let me answer that for you, SD:  62nd overall.  No one here is contending that Robinson is the kind of prospect coming out of school that Antwaan Randle-El was.  I'm saying he could go as early as 100 or so... that's a far cry from 62.

I am I think he is every bit the prospect Randle El was if not more because with his size he offers even more to the total package.  I agree with you if he fails it will be because he lacks a true position and has problems holding onto the ball.

[xtacy1238]

I love Michael Robinson as a football player. He has very good track speed for his size at 4.6 and he has even better football speed. He is a flat out playmaker! He will not make it past the 4th round! I would be suprised if he lated that long.

No as far as position with him who knows. I would put my money on WR/KR. I think College QB's can change to WR pretty easy.  Hines Ward, Anquon Boldin (played QB first 2yrs of college), Antwon Randle El, Drew Bennett to name a few.

[SidFarkus]

amazing how a trick play in the superbowl can elevate your status as a football player

Yeah, the fact that you catch 30 balls a year and are basically a punt returner is forgotten!

[ice grillin you]

what isnt forgotten is that he played across from a 100 catch guy in an offense that doesnt throw...doesnt leave much leftover

yous can argue all you want about whether he was worth the money...i dont play that game...but randel el will be a very good #2 wr

[Rome]

Even the notion of wasting a first day pick on him is ludacrisp.   

[Rome]

what isnt forgotten is that he played across from a 100 catch guy in an offense that doesnt throw...doesnt leave much leftover

yous can argue all you want about whether he was worth the money...i dont play that game...but randel el will be a very good #2 wr

IGY... don't we already have a very good #2 receiver in Reggie Brown?  That's why so many of us were against signing Randle El.  He'd be nothing but a very high priced redundancy in this offense.

Just sayin'...

[ice grillin you]

randel el automatically becomes the best wr on the eagles if signed...he greatly improves the team...i dont care if hes a number 1 or a number 10 wr...hes better than anything they have

the difference is the skins giants and taterskins will "overpay" to improve their teams...the eagles will not...if you believe in the eagles philosophy then more power to you...i personally think you have to do it at times

now that FA is over and the eagles have all that money left not getting someone like randel el makes a liottle more sense as its clear the eagles arent looking to win this year...and in year like this i have no problem not going out and paying for guys....its the years when youre on the brink of a superbowl and do little to nothing to get over the hump that i find disgraceful

the problem with this year is i believe the eagles had a chance to compete for  the conference

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

randel el automatically becomes the best wr on the eagles if signed...

Even if you assume Reggie Brown will be about the same as he was last year, he's still better than Randle-El at WR.

[ice grillin you]

right now randel el is better...one day reggie might be better...but whos to say

this year will show a lot...yes randel el is in a better offense...but reggie will be his teams number one guy...well see

either way whos really cares....randel el makes the eagles measureably better at both wr and kr

brown
randel el
gaffney

i would be happy with

randel el at PR id be estatic with

[SidFarkus]

what isnt forgotten is that he played across from a 100 catch guy in an offense that doesnt throw...doesnt leave much leftover

yous can argue all you want about whether he was worth the money...i dont play that game...but randel el will be a very good #2 wr

He was the #3 in Pittsburgh and in all likelihood will be the #3 in Washington.

[SunMo]

last year he was the #2, after they lost Burress.