Week 10 - Momentum to Miami NOPE CHIP SUCKS

[Sgt PSN]

Maclin had 3 catches for 17 yards on Sunday when K.C. scored 29 points.

Lol @ citing 1 game against an elite pass defense.  That makes sense.

How is Shady any better than what Mathews/Murray has given them?  Buffalo has him splitting time with Karlos Williams, for god's sake.

This makes less sense. You're knocking Shady for splitting time with Karlos Williams (who is pretty good), and wondering why his production isn't as good as a pair of guys who also split carries. If you're argument is that Murray>>>>Shady  (and that's the way it seems), then why would Murray defer carries to Mathews?  If he was that good, wouldn't Chip leave him out there more?

Personally I think the 2 are about a wash. Shady is better in the open field, Murray is more powerful. Both carry the ball like morons and have fumbling issues at times.

[ice grillin you]

murray is better with a zesty oline cause he will get tons of no gains versus shadys tackles for loss....but with a valid line and wr's ill take shady...really tho theres probably no appreciable difference btwn the two and definitely not when you have them surrounded by garbage at almost every position on offense....its whi its worthless to spend so much money on backs...you can pour half your payroll into the position and if some or all of your qb oline wr's stink then it doesnt matter

[smeags]

so let me get this straight, there's no chance the eagles wouldn be two games better at this point with a better rb (in this offense), a much better wr and better oline talent ?

also, can we really penalize maclin when his qb is capt checkdown ?

[Rome]

Once again... Shady hasn't been "much better" than the guys he was replaced by.  Maclin hasn't produced like he did last year.  In fact he's back to his career norms.  And Mathis would be marginally better than either of the guys he'd replace.

None of these factors alone or combined make the Eagles a 6-3 team.  Sorry.

[smeags]

so, the guys sent packing are better as you admit, just not enough to help the team win 2 more games out of 5 loses.

[ice grillin you]

why are you looking at current production...numbers are not a strong comparitive base in the nfl like they are in other sports....situation is so much more important....you cant compare mack in kc's offense to what he did in chips...its not that "mack hasnt produced like last year" rather its how would he have produced here versus huff or kkk....the upgrade would be ridiculous and worth enough additional pts in their losses....four of which totalled 16 pts....to the point they win a couple of those

shady i agree would not have made a huge difference

in terms of wins and losses i think you can make an argument that mathis wouldnt have made a difference either...although its arguable and hes a much bigger upgrade over their current guards than what you portray

[smeags]

No matter what you think the team stinks and there's one person to blame.

[SD]

Lurie

[hbionic]

Syrian refugees?

[Sgt PSN]

Obama.

[General_Failure]

You guys are stupid, I'm gonna blame Goodell.

[smeags]