Go on the record - Who is your starting QB?

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Top-rated passers in the NFC

Ha.

[ice grillin you]

the impressive number is the 11-2 td int ratio

[smeags]

donny boy anchoring the 11th spot.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

donny boy anchoring the 11th spot.

24th in the NFL (Vick is 1st and Kolb is 7th)

[smeags]

haaaa, 24th, has mama mcnabb blogged about lil d's season so far ?

[Don Ho]

fargin offense!  Top 2 QB's, 2 receivers in the top 10, Shady top 10 RB.  Beautiful.

[Munson]

Yeah I can't say I expected the offense to be as good as it's been, whether it was Kolb OR Vick. The line just looked so putrid...but they're finding ways to get it done

[Tomahawk]

Playing against mediocore to horrible defenses probably helps

[Feva]

the impressive number is the 11-2 td int ratio

Word...and even one of those was just thrown up for grabs to end a game. Hell, you can even make an argument for the tip drill vs the Falcons. Point is...neither one of them is putting the ball right in the gut of any DB's. Pleasant surprise to this point.

[ice grillin you]

the impressive number is the 11-2 td int ratio

Word...and even one of those was just thrown up for grabs to end a game. Hell, you can even make an argument for the tip drill vs the Falcons. Point is...neither one of them is putting the ball right in the gut of any DB's. Pleasant surprise to this point.

i mentioned this last week in another thread but this is extra important this year because of the line play...giving up minus yardage via the sack doesnt sting nearly as much if you are always winning the TO battle

[The BIGSTUD]

I don't think you can make the call now. You need to see if Vick can play at a high level for the rest of the season. Especially against tough defenses. If Vick shows that he truly has transformed his game and is now a pass first passer and an accurate one at that then I go with Vick. Michael Vick with those legs and that cannon of an arm with accuracy is a top 5 QB in the NFL and one of the most dangerous players this league has ever seen.

But if he reverts somewhat back to the Atlanta Vick with 50% completion percentage games and missing routine throws then I go with Kolb in 2011. Either way I think you need to see what Vick gives you the rest of the season.

So 2010 - Vick no matter what
2011 - Vick if he continues great play, and Kolb if Vick doesn't.

[shorebird]

Vick might be studying the playbook more, and he might be thinking pass first, but none of that is going to all of a sudden make him accurate. And there is no way he's going to be as accurate a passer as Kolb has now shown us he can be. Against Atlanta he was 23-29 and over 300 yds. On the year he's 71 outta' 105 for a 67.6% record. And he's only started what, 5 games in the NFL? Look really close at that completion %. No way in hell does Vick ever approach that mark. I was sceptical about Kolb, but he's making a believer outta' me quick, fast and in a hurry. I've been watching the Eagles for a long time and I can't remember if any qb I've ever seen has been this accurate. I'd bet no. I can't believe that, after all thats been invested in Kolb, and what he's shown, that anyone out there actually still wants Vick to start. He's a backup, nothing more.

[shorebird]

I forgot to mention this, do you sit the offensive player of the week?? How would that go over?? imo, that'd be a serious Kolb mind farg.

[ice grillin you]

pump your brakes homie

[shorebird]

Yeah, I know, I'm getting excited, but I can'ts helps it.