Boneheaded playcalls courtesy of Andy Reid

[Hawk]

there were people walking along the sidewalk in georgetown by the bar we were at who said they honestly thought there was a fire or huge fight inside because of all the screaming and they swear the window frames on the outside of the place were moving

the upstairs floor was moving after the mack td...i honestly feared for the integrity of the building if pimp ran that punt back...then when it happened i wasnt even thinking about it nor did i care

You should have seen some of the looks I was getting on M street.  The fur coat crowd thought I was insane.

[PhillyGirl]

I was never either, and you should be flogged for that post

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

I flog myself daily regardless.

[MDS]

You used to be IGY and you're turning into Diomedes.

lol first funny FF post EVER

[SunMo]

great, get ready for a barrage now...

he's like shane victorino, he hits one homerun and he's swinging for the fences for weeks.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Lightbulbhead says Reid is coach of the year

[Sgt PSN]

The Eagles are better than anyone predicted but I'd have to go with Morris in Tampa or Haley in KC.  Although I will say that I think this has probably been Reid's most impressive year.

[ice grillin you]

vick is coach of the year

[phillymic2000]

Reid sucks, his playcalling and decisions in the NYG game were unforgivable! Luckily Vick has the skills to overcome that waste of a life.

[Diomedes]

I'm easing off on Reid these days.  Donovan was a much bigger problem than I thought.  He's flawed, but I'm not hammering at him right now.

[SD]

I'm easing off on Reid these days.  Donovan was a much bigger problem than I thought.  He's flawed, but I'm not hammering at him right now.

Agree with this. If anything I've gained a lot of respect for Reid...not so much as a gameday coach, but that he went so far above and beyond to coddle little Donny, who - like a spoiled brat - never fully appreciated what Reid did for him.

[Sgt PSN]

I'm easing off on Reid these days.  Donovan was a much bigger problem than I thought.  He's flawed, but I'm not hammering at him right now.

I'm leaning this way too. Reid still has his deficiencies but hes been pretty good this year. He sucks at challenging but a lot of that has to do with his coaches upstairs. The offense seems to run alot more smooth with either Vick or Kolb, especially in the no huddle.

I'm still a 5 fan but it's become increasingly evident that McNabb was by far a bigger reason for this teams short comings than Reid.

[rjs246]

And here I was all excited to he the only one thinking this way. Reid is still awful at time management and challenges but its becoming clear that much of the in game nonsense we've experienced over the years was Donovan more than Andy.

[Munson]

I don't know if it was Donovan more than Andy, or just the fact that Vick and his athletic abilities/new found QBing abilities are just better than McNabb's were, at least in his last few years.

Andy's still making retarded play calls and decisions.


Where he deserves praise is his work with quaterbacks. He turned AJ into a 2nd round pick. McNabb. Kolb looked pathetic his first couple years in TC and preseason, but he came out this year with more zip, more accuracy, quick timing, etc. And now he's turned Vick into a completely different QB. Not to mention he was Favre's QB coach.

[ice grillin you]

for three years ive been trying to tell you guys this...reid is not a good gameday coach but hes not the devil everyone has tried to make him out to be...especially when it comes to the run/pass thing that everyone loves to harp on...

and hes off the charts awesome in every other aspect of coaching