The 2010 Point and Laugh at the Eagles thread

[Munson]

Soooo those guys won SB's not because of their greatness, but because of their supporting cast...but McNabb never won and it was solely on him and had nothing to do with the slop he was constantly surrounded by?

Got you.

(I agree with you, those guys had great teams surrounding them...just funny when that gets brought up as a knock against them when we kill McNabb for not winning one with teams not nearly as good around him)

[DH]

Just because guys may be "better than him" doesnt put him into "tier 2". I didnt know there was a cap put on each "tier". And what determines "better than" anyway?

In closing, I hate using quotes and now hate you for making me overuse them.

[smeags]

munson, may be that whole game ending int thingy but i could be wrong.

[Munson]

I don't think you "overused" them.


But if you really wanna put him in the same stratosphere as Manning and Brady, be my guest.

[PhillyGirl]

I just don't see him as the guy who will lead this team to a Super Bowl. I'm not talking about him having a noodle arm or anything like that.

The guy just oozes Bobby Hoying to me.

And oh my God, I hope he proves me to be dead wrong.

[Diomedes]

Great Kolb has a noble arm!

[Rome]

Who is this Cobb dude you're all talking about?

[Drunkmasterflex]

I just don't see him as the guy who will lead this team to a Super Bowl. I'm not talking about him having a noodle arm or anything like that.

The guy just oozes Bobby Hoying to me.

And oh my God, I hope he proves me to be dead wrong.

There is no comparison to Bobby Hoying the two are completely different.  I understand the fact that people use it as how he will be a bust.  The thing is though if he is a bust it will be much worse than Hoying.  Hoying wasn't replacing a perennial Pro Bowl QB. 

[mussa]

Is it farging September yet?

[Diomedes]

yes...in just a few weeks, you'll be shoveling snow into your pickup truck bed

[DH]

But if you really wanna put him in the same stratosphere as Manning and Brady, be my guest.

I never said that..that's ridiculous. But there's a cute little place somewhere in between those two and the "tier 2" guys and that's where Rodgers is.

My initial and only point is saying that Rodgers is tier 2 QB (whatever the farg that is I dont know), like you did is ridiculous. 

[Rome]

You're all tier 1 guys to me.[/wub]

[General_Failure]

This concept of wub disgusts and infuriates us!

[MDS]

I just don't see him as the guy who will lead this team to a Super Bowl. I'm not talking about him having a noodle arm or anything like that.

The guy just oozes Bobby Hoying to me.

And oh my God, I hope he proves me to be dead wrong.

There is no comparison to Bobby Hoying the two are completely different.  I understand the fact that people use it as how he will be a bust.  The thing is though if he is a bust it will be much worse than Hoying.  Hoying wasn't replacing a perennial Pro Bowl QB. 

exactly

pg drinks the crazy juice, it how she rolls and its part of her charm. im done fighting with her about this, nothing is changing her view.

[shorebird]

I don't see how, after just two games, you can compare Kolb to any player or really know anything about him. He had good games against NO and KC the second and third week of the season. I'll admit, he was good in those two starts, but it's still only two friggen' games.