The Eagles will win the Superbowl next year

[MDS]

haha, and everyone is frightened to go up against mcnabb

put $ where your mouth is. any amount of money the eagles dont win the superbowl, let alone make it.

[ice grillin you]

none of those qb's is 1-6 in championship games

like it or not that will be mcnabbs legacy in this league

[Munson]

I'm not saying they're going to win the Super Bowl.

And I'm not saying teams should be fearing McNabb.


I do think however that McNabb and his surrounding cast would be a bit more effective if the coaching and play calling didn't look like it was being called in by you.


Everyone knows McNabb is on and off...you have 3 RB's to offset making him throw that much. And yet you only use them 7 times.



Not smrt.

[SunMo]

[homers]but...but...but you have to make it that many championship games to have that record!  at least there's that![/homers]

[ice grillin you]

i love how donovan never had weapons and thats why he didnt win anything....now he has weapons and the coaching is why he doesnt win anything

the excuses never cease to amaze

[Munson]

none of those qb's is 1-6 in championship games

like it or not that will be mcnabbs legacy in this league

that's because none of them have ever made it there lolol. And look at the teams McNabb used to do it with...sheesh. There's no way James Thrash should be the #1 WR of an NFC Championship team...


Out of seriouls curiousity, what is Favre's playoff record since 1998? I know they've won a couple, but if memory serves he's only been to the NFCCG once since 1997.....maybe twice? Either way he didn't win em....

[MDS]

god i keep forgetting how good weaver is, how mccoy can pick up blitz packages and how its 2004 so by golly we must use westbrook!

again, i point you to the drives mcnabb had to win/tie against st louis and arizona. the epic choke against tampa. the no show against carolina and the puking and 2 dreadful ints against the pats.

that had nothing to do with coaching everything to do with mcnabb coming up short on his ownself.

[PhillyPhreak54]

[homers]but...but...but you have to make it that many championship games to have that record!  at least there's that![/homers]

[haters]but...but...but he threw the ball 5 inches to the left of his number and that is inexcusable! He puked on the field![/haters]

You guys act like he's Quincy Carter

[SunMo]

i wonder how we know that Jason Avant has such great hands?

oh yeah, it's because he's constantly making fantastic catches on terrible throws by Donovan, that's how.

[Munson]

again, i point you to the drives mcnabb had to win/tie against st louis and arizona. the epic choke against tampa. the no show against carolina and the McNabb, that sweet hunk of man meat, and 2 dreadful ints against the pats.

that had nothing to do with coaching everything to do with mcnabb coming up short on his ownself.

I don't recall ever saying he didn't choke in those games....?



And McNabb did get them the lead despite being down by 20+ points at one point during the Arizona game....why didn't the defense hold that lead?

[Eagles_Legendz]

Brees
Favre
Romo
Warner
Rodgers
McNabb

Manning
Rivers
Brady
Palmer
Sanchez
Flacco

How many of those quarterbacks do you take over McNabb THIS YEAR in the playoffs?

Manning, Rivers, Brady, Brees, and Warner should be automatic.

You could easily make a case for Rodgers/Romo/Favre/Palmer too.

I'd rather have McNabb than Favre and Palmer but someone could easily make a case the only two QBs in the playoffs that they'd rather have McNabb over are Sanchez and Flacco.

[Munson]

i wonder how we know that Jason Avant has such great hands?

oh yeah, it's because he's constantly making fantastic catches on terrible throws by Donovan, that's how.

Making catches thrown a little bit behind you are not "fantastic"...they're catches that are supposed to be made if they're hitting you in both hands. Period.

[SunMo]

haha, yes, that throw was "a little" behind Maclin and had a very catchable pace too...

[Munson]

Brees
Favre
Romo
Warner
Rodgers
McNabb

Manning
Rivers
Brady
Palmer
Sanchez
Flacco

How many of those quarterbacks do you take over McNabb THIS YEAR in the playoffs?

Manning, Rivers, Brady, Brees, and Warner should be automatic.

You could easily make a case for Rodgers/Romo/Favre/Palmer too.

I'd rather have McNabb than Favre and Palmer but someone could easily make a case the only two QBs in the playoffs that they'd rather have McNabb over are Sanchez and Flacco.

Manning and Brady are automatic. Warner too.

The rest, ESPECIALLY Rivers, have done less in the playoffs with more to work with. What have they done to prove they could take this Eagles team to the SB and win it? Rivers hasn't been able to do with with Gates and LT who were, at the time, the best players at their posisitions in all of football.

[MDS]

again, i point you to the drives mcnabb had to win/tie against st louis and arizona. the epic choke against tampa. the no show against carolina and the McNabb, that sweet hunk of man meat, and 2 dreadful ints against the pats.

that had nothing to do with coaching everything to do with mcnabb coming up short on his ownself.

I don't recall ever saying he didn't choke in those games....?



And McNabb did get them the lead despite being down by 20+ points at one point during the Arizona game....why didn't the defense hold that lead?

boom, there it is.

mcnabb had all the time in the world and about half the field to the tie game. he failed. end of story.