Grade Day 1

[ice grillin you]

Macklin - C

Shady - A

Day - B

[PhillyPhanInDC]

Maclin: C+. I'm still trying to come around on this. One of his knocks was that he isn't a consistent route runner, which equals little time in game in Reid's offense.

Shady: B+. A lot of what they needed. I really think he winds up eclipsing Westy by the end of the year, and becomes THE guy in two seasons, with Westy wrapping it up.

Overall: B. I like the picks, but I am unsure how much Maclin helps them right away. Shady needs to touch the ball 10+ times a game, minimum.

[DH]

Mack - B
Shady - A

Day 1 - A...I know the math isnt right, but we could look back at this day in 5 years and say that today was the day that was the turning point for the franchise - for the offense, at least...or we could have another pinkston/hamner duo...who knows, but the potential for the former is better than that of the latter.

[BigEd76]

A-

they got two guys that could have been top 5 picks in next year's draft and only gave up the Kelly Holcomb 6th-rder to get them.  Most had Maclin as a top-7 pick or no later than 10.

TE and CB are next on the want list.....maybe trade a bunch of those 5s to get back into the 4th

[DH]

STOP CALLING HIM WESTY

[SD_Eagle5]

Macklin - C

Shady - A

Day - B

yup

[PhillyPhanInDC]

STOP CALLING HIM WESTY

Wsty?

[DH]

STOP CALLING HIM WESTY

Wsty?

Westbrook.

Is it that farging hard? Westy is the stupidest name ever...my blood literally boils when I hear someone call him that. Im turning into IGY.

[ice grillin you]

STOP CALLING HIM WESTY

ha

he def doesnt play hockey


so does macklin get pimps PR touches or with demps a possible starter does he only get his KR's

i wont be very happy if pimp becomes a full time wr

[Eagles_Legendz]

I'd give both Maclin and McCoy a B+.

Once Moreno was gone, there was no one besides Pettigrew that I would have preferred at 21 (would have considered Donald Brown), and McCoy seems to be a good fit for the offense.  I think they got good value out of both of the picks, though I would rather have traded the 1st for Boldin.

[DH]

Mack - KR
Pimp - PR

Mack, Pimp & Shady...I farging love it.

[ice grillin you]

shady be mackin and pimpin

[ice grillin you]

Mack - KR
Pimp - PR

the more i think about this the more i think hes gonna take over both duties...just because pimp proved hes worthy of full time wr status and does anyone see macklin getting real run at wr next year?

[Rome]

A++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

[DH]

Im sure Andy sees what Pimp did at WR last year and will let Mack do his thing out there