Donovan McNabb

[MDS]

from the start he was the only child that mattered

or else hes just the most self centered person on earth

[Rome]

Every last one of you would have kissed his ass at Broad & Pattison if he had won a Super Bowl, so stop your goddamn nonsense.

[MDS]

probably...but he didnt and it was never going to happen

then again id kiss brad goebels ass for a title

[ice grillin you]

Every last one of you would have kissed his ass at Broad & Pattison if he had won a Super Bowl, so stop your goddamn nonsense.

not a chance in hell

i dont whore myself out for titles and my affection does not have a price tag on it

[PhillyPhreak54]

lol so you'd be in the corner giving him the gas face eh?

[Rome]

Every last one of you would have kissed his ass at Broad & Pattison if he had won a Super Bowl, so stop your goddamn nonsense.

not a chance in hell

i dont whore myself out for titles and my affection does not have a price tag on it

this is the mount everest of internet bullshtein.

[ice grillin you]

lol so you'd be in the corner giving him the gas face eh?

i dont hate him cause he didnt win a title i hate him because hes a delusional bedwetting cornball

i cant stand victorino and he won a world series with the phils...not a big heidi fan either...just because your team wins it all doesnt mean you have to like all the players on the team

buddy ryan never won a playoff game and he is literally a god....the buddy eagles are legend...so are the mid 80's flyers...and allen iverson

titles or the lack thereof and love for individual players are mutually exclusive

[Eagaholic]

I think how we would remember McNabb if he won a SB would largely be influenced by how he played. If he had a shtein the bed Roethlisberger performance v Seattle I could see a lot of people still hating him. If he was strap he team on his back MVP then no, most fans would be very forgiving, especially after he finally left the team.

It's still possible hate a championship player though. I always hated pete rose, still do. I was thrilled he had that catch out of Bob Boone's glove but after the WS I still couldn't stand him. Maybe it as a little different because he had been on a rival team first, but he'd still be an icehole in my book.

Speaking of that catch, it got me to thinking of great Philles moments. None are more iconic to me than McGraw jumping off the mound. Here is a nice clip of him talking of it. When I saw it on youtube there was a great bacon commercial on before it with a girl in a bacon bra, hope it is still there.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2qxkxdimxZE

[QB Eagles]

I think everyone is kind of right in this thread. If McNabb sacked up for one Super Bowl and carried the team on his back to a victory, he'd be appreciated in Philly today, but probably not loved. Also igy and a minority of other fans would still dislike him intensely.

Also I wouldn't criticize igy over it. Having guys you like and guys you hate no matter what is a perfectly valid approach to sports. I don't think he used the phrase "mutually exclusive" in a valid way though.

[Sgt PSN]

If McNabb sacked up for one Super Bowl and carried the team on his back to a victory, he'd be appreciated in Philly today, but probably not loved.

This probably says it better than any of us have so far.  Fans would def appreciate the trophy, but he'd still never be able to win over the majority and eventually they'd still get sick of his shtein.

[hbionic]

Every last one of you would have kissed his ass at Broad & Pattison if he had won a Super Bowl, so stop your goddamn nonsense.

not a chance in hell

i dont whore myself out for titles and my affection does not have a price tag on it

this is the mount everest of internet bullshtein.

[Sgt PSN]

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-draft/0ap2000000166935/Will-Barkley-make-an-impact-with-the-Eagles

Here's something for Havas and Todd to stroke each other to.  I laughed at the end because there was no babies close by for me to punch. 

[ice grillin you]

i dont know if im more mad at you for posting that or me for watching it....either way im physically ill right now...my god him cockily saying that the eagles are going to be retiring his number soon is bng my meatcicle into a wall annoying

oh and hes still as uncomfotably unfunny as it gets

[MDS]

im not if its donovan or roger ailes but one of them is the worst person ever

[SD]

According to Paul Donowitch on Twitter, Donovan McNabb will retire as an Eagle this season and it looks like it will happen when Andy Reid and the Chiefs come to town.