It's time for Reid to GO!!!!!!

[Phanatic]

The Eagles are only a year or two away from a complete rebuild anyway. Can a coaching staff really survive that?

[shorebird]

The Eagles are only a year or two away from a complete rebuild anyway. Can a coaching staff really survive that?

This one could. I don't think Ried will be gone until he retires.

[Cerevant]

With the eventual success of coaches like Cowher and Dungy, we can count on Andy being around for a long time.

[bobbyinlondon]

Sean Payton, Bill Belichek, Mike Shanahan, Tony Dungy, Lovie Smith and a bit of a push but Jeff Fisher. And then any coach that knows how to make in game adjustments... then Reid.

Well, let's see---

Sean Payton--where's his SB ring? Didn't his offense get absolutely hammered in a SB when he OC of the Giants? And wasn't his playcalling so bad the Giants replaced him?

Mike Shanahan--he's done nothing since Elway retired. And what people forget is his two SB trophies are tarnished just like Belicheck's. They were found guilty of circumventing the salary cap both years they won it.

Tony Dungy--he's been coaching since '96--how many trips to the playoffs did it take for him to win his Lombardi?

Lovie Smith--he won a SB ring as a DC, but what makes you think he's a better HC than Reid? Especially when he sticks with a disaster like Grossman at QB.

Fisher's had more down years than up years. Where's his SB ring as a HC?

[rjs246]

Bobby. Stop it. The question isn't who has a superbowl ring. The question is who is a better in-game coach than Reid. And the answer is everyone.

If you honestly think that Reid is on par with any of those coaches in terms of in-game coaching and adjustments you are out of your goddamned mind.

[Wingspan]

Bobby. Stop it. The question isn't who has a superbowl ring. The question is who is a better in-game coach than Reid. And the answer is everyone.

If you honestly think that Reid is on par with any of those coaches in terms of in-game coaching and adjustments you are out of your goddamned mind.

Yes, that is exactly the question. The person who supplied this list always goes to "the super bowl win is most important"

[ice grillin you]

every situation for every coach is different in more than one way...it doesnt matter what sean payton did as the giants OC or lovie smith as a DC...

the question is are there more than a couple coaches out there that would have won a superbowl with the eagles over the last five years and the answer is a resounding yes imo

[Phanatic]

Not that I really care but in Dungy's defense he took over a terrible franchise in Tampa and made them into a superbowl team. I've always kind of gave him credit for TBs Super bowl run the year after he left because Gruden sucks...

[rjs246]

The Superbowl win IS the most important. And any of those coaches, given the Eagles NFCCG teams, would have come away with a ring because they wouldn't have stopped running the ball in the second half, hideously mis-managed the clock, and been out-coached in every possible way. Andy Reid is an in-game hack.

What he is good at, what he needs is a complete disaster area of a team to calmly guide to success. He took the Eagles from laughing stock to top tier. But he will never, ever out-coach his peers until he learns to adjust his farging game-plans to account for his opponents.

[Rome]

He's creeping closer to "complete disaster area" with each passing (forgive the pun) season.

[TexasEagle]

Bobby. Stop it. The question isn't who has a superbowl ring. The question is who is a better in-game coach than Reid. And the answer is everyone.

If you honestly think that Reid is on par with any of those coaches in terms of in-game coaching and adjustments you are out of your goddamned mind.

Yes, that is exactly the question. The person who supplied this list always goes to "the super bowl win is most important"

No, the question I answered with the list of coaches is "who's better" than Andy Reid as a head coach. Which doesn't have anything to do with the Super Bowl being the most important thing for an NFL team, which it is. I swear it's like your arguing just to argue but you have no point.

There's better head coaches than Andy Reid and teams play an NFL season to WIN THE SUPER BOWL. Seriously, I don't know why some of you are getting your panties in a twist over this.

[Geowhizzer]

YOU PLAY TO WIN THE GAME!

[Rome]

YOU PLAY TO WIN THE AIDS!

[Geowhizzer]

YOU PLAY TO WIN THE AIDS!

I guess you win then! 

[TexasEagle]

There's better head coaches than Andy Reid...

As I said!