Kevin Kolb, Philadelphia Eagle

[Tomahawk]

Sam Bradford has been looking good and doesn't have the experience of Kolb

[Munson]

Or the surrounding cast. An Eagles PS castoff is their leading WR


To be fair, I liked Danny Amendola.

[SD]

Sam Bradford has been looking good and doesn't have the experience of Kolb

He has about the same as far as games go and he's played 4 straight

[Munson]

Same as far as games go does not make up for the 3+ years Kolb has had to learn the offense.

Nor does he have all pro WR's and an all pro TE to throw to.

[Hawk]

Or the surrounding cast. An Eagles PS castoff is their leading WR


To be fair, I liked Danny Amendola.

Mark Clayton was on the Eagles PS??

[Diomedes]

Bradford looks good.  Kolb does not.

These are facts, sure.  So what. 

[Munson]

Or the surrounding cast. An Eagles PS castoff is their leading WR


To be fair, I liked Danny Amendola.

Mark Clayton was on the Eagles PS??

Ah, forgot about Clayton.

They're all bums

[SD]

Same as far as games go does not make up for the 3+ years Kolb has had to learn the offense.

Nor does he have all pro WR's and an all pro TE to throw to.

Kolb did fine with those same WRs and TE last season when he threw back to back 300 yard games. This season he's played a quarter and a half and a half. Not exactly enough to go off of.

[Hawk]

Kolb will throw for 320 yds and 3 tds this weekend.

[QB Eagles]

In all likelihood, Kolb is going to start the next three games. It'll probably make more sense to evaluate him then. We probably still won't know his ceiling, but if there is absolutely zero improvement between now and then, I don't think anyone will be too broken up over shipping him off to another team before next season.

[Munson]

Same as far as games go does not make up for the 3+ years Kolb has had to learn the offense.

Nor does he have all pro WR's and an all pro TE to throw to.

Kolb did fine with those same WRs and TE last season when he threw back to back 300 yard games. This season he's played a quarter and a half and a half. Not exactly enough to go off of.

I don't think he's a total bum, but do you really think he looks good enough or will ever be good enough to lead an Andy Reid led team to the SB?

Because let's be honest, we're not going to be happy with this team until they win a SB.

[SD]

I don't know, but I'd like to find out before I start calling him a bum. What I'd like to see is progression at this point. He needs reps to see if he has what it takes.

[Munson]

I still think he ends up average/slightly above average. He'll be brilliant some weeks and terrible some weeks. Which aint bad. They can and will win games with that.

But I don't think anyone complaining about the last 11 years can be okay with that. Because it doesn't win Super Bowls. Andy Reid will never have the run game/dominating defense that it takes to win with just a good QB.

Hopefully he's not scared shteinless out there this week and we can get a good look at all the downfield vision, accuracy, and quick releases we've been hearing about all off-season.

[SunMo]

playing a half, getting a concussion, then not playing for two games, being made the backup, and then having to come in to play 3 quarters is definitely all i need to know that Kolb is a terrible qb and human being.

[Drunkmasterflex]

Sam Bradford has been looking good and doesn't have the experience of Kolb

Sam Bradford already looks better than most NFL Qbs.