Reid

[Sgt PSN]

Ya know, silly as this may sound, but with the type of players this team has on offense I'm thinking Vermeil would actually be a good choice.  I'm certain he's done coaching now but he makes sense as a HC possibility.  [/crack dream]

[shorebird]

I'd like to see Chucky come back, if anyone does replace Reid. At least he knows what it takes to win a Superbowl.

[MURP]

I cant take Reid anymore.  Reid isnt going to change.   Bottom line he got to one superbowl and lost.    So did Jim Fassell.   Things are a little rosey at the moment with the Eagles last few wins, but fact  is that this year was disgusting.  Lets see what everyone thinks next season when Reid bumbles with horrible clock management, awful playcalling, telling us that he needs to put people in a better position to make plays, yadda yadda.   Even if there isnt a better coaching option out there atleast I can watch them obtain the same results without seeing his fat stupid head sweating after every loss.

[shorebird]

Also, Gruden would most definalty call out McNabb.

[Sgt PSN]

Don't hold back Murp.  Tell us how you really feel.  

[Quasimoto]

Someone needs to go after this season.  If it isn't Reid it's Jim Johnson.  Our D sucks.

[shorebird]

Even if there isnt a better coaching option out there atleast I can watch them obtain the same results without seeing his fat stupid head sweating after every loss.

Get a fathead!!

[Sgt PSN]

Also, Gruden would most definalty call out McNabb.

I think any new coach the Eagles would bring in would call out McNabb when needed.  Reid is the only person in the world who won't do it because he treat Donovan like his first born son.  

[Philly_Crew]

So you really want Gruden, who although he won a Super Bowl with Tony Dungy's team, is 3-11 this year, 11-5 in 2005, 5-11 in 2004, 7-11 in 2003?

[Sgt PSN]

So you really want Gruden, who although he won a Super Bowl with Tony Dungy's team, is 3-11 this year, 11-5 in 2005, 5-11 in 2004, 7-11 in 2003?

  7-9 maybe? 

[ice grillin you]

That makes no sense.

talking live on the radio for four hours is a little different than pre taping 17 minutes worth of television

[phillywin2k5]

I cant take Reid anymore.  Reid isnt going to change.   Bottom line he got to one superbowl and lost.    So did Jim Fassell.   Things are a little rosey at the moment with the Eagles last few wins, but fact  is that this year was disgusting.  Lets see what everyone thinks next season when Reid bumbles with horrible clock management, awful playcalling, telling us that he needs to put people in a better position to make plays, yadda yadda.   Even if there isnt a better coaching option out there atleast I can watch them obtain the same results without seeing his fat stupid head sweating after every loss.

Eagles need some major help beginning next season.
a) need to fire Pete Jenkins and (for the 6th consecutive year) Dave Culley
b) need to get a run stuffing DT, enough with the speed crap
c) CUT RENO MAHE, any other KR would taken that ball for 6
d) Reid needs to give up talent evaluation, game planning, play calling, and take a class on time management!
e) resign Stallworth.
f) CUT TRA "im good for 15 yards in penalties every game" Thomas
g) get a BIG BACK for short yardage
h) dump the Air Guitar bowtie guy
i) stop relying on Mcnabb

[Feva]

To me... it's pretty simple. 

AS A COACH:

If you think Andy has truly turned a corner on his playcalling (of giving the responsibility up), using a balanced attack, clock management, in-game adjustments, and a little emotion like we've seen the last few weeks... I wouldn't mind seeing him stay around.

If you think Andy is simply biding his time until McNabb comes back so he can stubbornly go right back to throwing the ball every down, getting plays in at the last second... and dropping everything on McNabb again... then he needs to go.  Now.


But remember... this is the same guy who it took 5 years to admit that his team needed WR help.


AS A GM:

Holla at cha boy.

[ice grillin you]

i cant see reid firing any of his peoples...johnson might 'retire' as others have mentioned but i just cant envision reid outright firing someone like dave culley

tra thomas has had a great year i dont know what youre watching...as long as hes healthy hes has to come back as i dont wanna go into next season with winston justice or bust at LT...altho i suppose herremans could move out and mjg move in at guard

agree on stallworth....he has to be re upped...no excuses

[SunMo]

Andy isn't much better as a GM than he is a coach.  if i had to choose one, i'd rather have him as the coach.