McNabb's Remark

[ice grillin you]

fine
you win
mcnabb is better than manning
i dont have time for this anymore

[SD_Eagle5]

fine
you win
mcnabb is better than manning
i dont have time for this anymore

Nope, never said McNabb was better. Just said he doesn't get the credit he deserves and that in the playoffs when it counts the most he's better than Manning.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

McNabb gets plenty of credit and plenty of criticism.  Much of it is undeserved.

[Wingspan]

fine
you win
mcnabb is better than manning
i dont have time for this anymore

Nope, never said McNabb was better. Just said he doesn't get the credit he deserves and that in the playoffs when it counts the most he's better than Manning.

i said mcnabb was better than manning. and i still say that.

[The BIGSTUD]

So when McNabb lost to the eventual superbowl champs, he gets no credit.

sure he gets credit...even tho he singlehandedly lost the game for them....hes just not as good as manning

The defense lost that game for them. McNabb and TO were the only reasons they were even in the game. Plus the interior line on both sides of the ball got totally dominated.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

For every great play McNabb made in the Super Bowl, he made a bad one.

That said, he played a lot better than the winning QB of Super Bowl XL did... not that that means anything at all.

[shorebird]

unless he wins a sb mcnabb is just another very good qb in this league...hes in with a hundred others of his kind...hes joe theisman without a superbowl...

You should at the very least be flogged within' an inch of your life for that comment.
....and then banned...
....and then tied to a chair and made to listen to Joe Blow talk football until your ears burn off.

Give McNabb an Art Monk clone and you would see how dumb that sounds.

[ice grillin you]

mcnabb 3 ints and his cluelessness in the final minutes lost the game

mcnabb 3 int
brady 0 int

thats your game right there

patriots gave up more yards and first downs and the eagles had a better 3rd down conversion rate

so if the eagles defense lost the game then how bad was the patriots defense?

it was bad enough to win the game because of the heinous red zone turnovers by mcnabb in the first half and him letting the patriots off the hook by inexplicably running the last four minutes of the game off he clock

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

unless he wins a sb mcnabb is just another very good qb in this league...hes in with a hundred others of his kind...hes joe theisman without a superbowl...

You should at the very least be flogged within' an inch of your life for that comment.
....and then banned...
....and then tied to a chair and made to listen to Joe Blow talk football until your ears burn off.

Give McNabb an Art Monk clone and you would see how dumb that sounds.

IGY is on the record as saying he thinks Theezman is a good looking guy.

[The BIGSTUD]

mcnabb 3 ints and his cluelessness in the final minutes lost the game

mcnabb 3 int
brady 0 int

thats your game right there

patriots gave up more yards and first downs and the eagles had a better 3rd down conversion rate

so if the eagles defense lost the game then how bad was the patriots defense?

it was bad enough to win the game because of the heinous red zone turnovers by mcnabb in the first half and him letting the patriots off the hook by inexplicably running the last four minutes of the game off he clock

Not all the INTs were his fault, and you can credit those INTs to some of the pressure through the interior that the Pats brought.

Also the end of the game was NOT on McNabb. That was on the coaches. It wasn't his choice to take his time at the end of the game.

[ice grillin you]

Give McNabb an Art Monk clone and you would see how dumb that sounds.

so when all is said and done mcnabbs legacy will be that he was a great qb because he never had a wr like art monk...not because of anything he ever accomplished (whether it be great numbers or a ring)

man im sure he will be proud of that

[ice grillin you]

Not all the INTs were his fault, and you can credit those INTs to some of the pressure through the internet that the Pats brought.

Also the end of the game was NOT on McNabb

what is on mcnabb exactly?

other than those hideous soup commercials


ps- theeseman IS HOTT

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Again, McNabb was a non-factor in the Super Bowl because he cancelled himself out by making his share of plays for the Patriots as well as some plays for the Eagles.  The big underlying issue was that the Eagles were beaten on both lines.  HOWEVER, if McNabb had played like an elite QB, the Eagles would have won the game.  I don't think he had much of an opportunity to do so, but great players can beat adversity.  McNabb was not a great player in that game.

[shorebird]

Give McNabb an Art Monk clone and you would see how dumb that sounds.

so when all is said and done mcnabbs legacy will be that he was a great qb because he never had a wr like art monk...not because of anything he ever accomplished (whether it be great numbers or a ring)

man im sure he will be proud of that

Might as well say he didn't have John Riggens in the backfield either.

[SD_Eagle5]

Again, McNabb was a non-factor in the Super Bowl because he cancelled himself out by making his share of plays for the Patriots as well as some plays for the Eagles.  The big underlying issue was that the Eagles were beaten on both lines.  HOWEVER, if McNabb had played like an elite QB, the Eagles would have won the game.  I don't think he had much of an opportunity to do so, but great players can beat adversity.  McNabb was not a great player in that game.

I'll always counter this argument with the lack of running plays Reid failed to call. Any player in this league that throws 51 passes against an excellent Pats D is going to make some mistakes, I put the onus on Reid for not even trying to establish a running game.