McNabb's Remark

[Don Ho]

.   Oh yeah, brilliant strategy not having someone to return the punt either.  Go team.   

About as much success rate as an onside kick.  I am still fuming about those genius calls.

[PhillyPhreak54]

I love how clowns hide behind the "realist" tag when bashing the team. Admit that youre a hater and get out from behind the "realist" cloak. I also like how people start off a good bash session by stating how long they have owned season tickets, been a fan or how they want to win as much as anyone.

We all have our opinions. Yours are on the hater side of things. Admit it. Embrace the darkside and live with it. And then man up when McNabb proves you wrong.

Phreak, you HAVE to get off the homer tip. There is a farging massive amount of real estate between your opinion of McNabb and actually 'hating' him. And believe me, reality lies in between. Your homerism has rocketed off the charts recently and frankly, you're embarrassing yourself.

I love that McNabb (along with Reid) have brought respectability, stability and occasional dominance to this team. I love his ability and occasionally love his attitude. He's obviously one of the better Qbs in the NFL right now and has been an effective leader.

I hate that McNabb (along with Reid) have ruined this franchise's best opportunities to win a championship over the past 6 years. He has come up so small when the stakes were he highest that only a blinded taterskins-esque homer would not see it.

You're the one who obsessively posts Art's quotes from ES in the point and laugh thread and you're sounding more and more like him by the second...

Not really. I just hate it when people who have a negative point of view on something use the term "realist" when stating thier opinion. I hear it all the time.

I don't care if you are a person who has a negative point of view. That's cool. Everyone has their own opinion. But don't paint a pile of shtein white and call it a snowman.

If you want to think something, go right ahead. I am generally half-full on my outlook. But I don't tell you that I'm being a realist when I say that. I say what I think and that's it. I do not try to say it like its fact and I am letting you all on a big secret like the folks who say "I'm a realist...." and then go into the negative aspect of things. What makes that person a realist? All they are doing is stating their opinon.

And thank you for comparing me to Art. I have a gun and a bullet and I'm ending it....now.

[ice grillin you]

That's not what I said at all. McNabb has shown he can actually lead his team to a Superbowl. Talk to me when Manning does that.

mcnabb did it once...against a weak championship game oppoenent....whereas manning has lost to the superbowl champion the last three years

since the jets debacle in 2002 manning has actually been a better playoff qb against better competition...it was mannings first couple playoff games where he struggled...then again so did mcnabb...but in the last 3-4 years manning is better than mcnabb in numbers he has just happened to run into the qb that you say is clearly the best in the world (brady) and plays in a superior conference

manning is in another league as a qb than mcnabb




The whole lot of you McNabb uber-homers are nuts.  I love the guy, but he definitely has a few screws loose, and the way he's wired lends itself to some very questionable on-and-off-field decisions... and sometimes it seems like he doesn't have the strength of will to win that some of the great QB's of the present and past have had.


this is all that needs to be said....It burns when I pee

[Wingspan]

...it was mannings first couple playoff games where he struggled...then again so did mcnabb...but in the last 3-4 years manning is better than mcnabb in numbers he has just happened to run into the qb that you say is clearly the best in the world (brady) and plays in a superior conference

manning is in another league as a qb than mcnabb

4 of 6 playoff appearances...manning lost in the 1st game.

the colts were down 21-3 in the 4th qtr before he threw his only TD

in 2004, after lighting up the broncos...he failed to score a TD vs the pats and lost 20-3

shut out in 2002 vs the jets.

manning lost his 1st three playoff games, where as mcnabb won 4 before before he lost his third

manning is a choker. he runs up the score vs pansies in the regular season, and hardly ever plays with any kind of consistancy when it matters.

manning = a-rod 
brady = jeter
mcnabb = ortiz

[ice grillin you]

mcnabb = the braves without a world series

[MURP]

"I'm not here to make friends, I'm here to win ballgames"

OMG McNabb isnt as good as Peyton Manning.  OMG McNabb sucks unless he wins the superbowl.   TO and Racism and World Wars, rape and pillage, apocolypse.  oh my.  rabble rabble rabble.

[Wingspan]

mcnabb = the braves without a world series

for now, i buy that

[Wingspan]

rabble rabble rabble.

thats ridiculous

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

mcnabb = the braves without a world series

That would be a good analogy, except for all the parts of it that suck.

[Rome]

mcnabb = the braves without a world series

That would be a good analogy, except for all the parts of it that suck.

[SidFarkus]

That's not what I said at all. McNabb has shown he can actually lead his team to a Superbowl. Talk to me when Manning does that.

mcnabb did it once...against a weak championship game oppoenent....whereas manning has lost to the superbowl champion the last three years

So when McNabb lost to the eventual superbowl champs, he gets no credit. However, Manning does get credit for that. When McNabb get's his team to the superbowl, he gets no credit and you make excuses... When Manning fails to even get his team to a championship game for years, he gets credit for that.

It just sounds like you're inventing reasons. Peyton Manning is a great fantasy football player, which is how you appear to be looking at it. He's done very little in his career to prove he "in another league" than McNabb as far QBs go. That's just fantasy football talk.

[ice grillin you]

So when McNabb lost to the eventual superbowl champs, he gets no credit.

sure he gets credit...even tho he singlehandedly lost the game for them....hes just not as good as manning

[SD_Eagle5]

So when McNabb lost to the eventual superbowl champs, he gets no credit.

sure he gets credit...even tho he singlehandedly lost the game for them....hes just not as good as manning

Manning and the Colts managed 3 points vs. the same Pats team that McNabb and the Eagles put 21 on.

[ice grillin you]

in the snow at new england vs a neutral site with what was essentially an eagles home crowd....not exactly the same thing...in fact had the eagles been in the afc they go down just as hard in that situation

[SD_Eagle5]

in the snow at new england vs a neutral site with what was essentially an eagles home crowd....not exactly the same thing...in fact had the eagles been in the afc they go down just as hard in that situation

Way to spin it, it was cold but it was hardly snowing. The Pats didn't seem to have a problem moving the ball, here's a shot of Manning late in the 4th, where's all this snow you're talking about?



And I find it extremely funny that McNabb played vs. the Falcons in worse conditions but is given no credit by you.