Would you trade Brian Westbrook for LaDainian Tomlinson?

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

I would.

[MURP]

yep.

[Diomedes]

Without hesitation, yes.

[Wingspan]

no doubt. holla dook

[rjs246]

Dude. The mere suggestion makes me erect.

[General_Failure]

I'd throw in Trotter too.

[Sgt PSN]

Football.  Wood. 

[rjs246]

I can honestly say that I would never even think about Westbrook again if this imaginary trade were to happen. The difference between the two is astronomical.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

I think the overall difference between McNabb and Manning is pretty big, too.  I guess that's my point.

[General_Failure]

We get that Skippy. Thanks for pointing it out though.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Some people need their hand held to grasp the obvious.

[General_Failure]

You goin' Chuggie on us?

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Don't let your fantasy taint everyone else's reality, E.W.

[General_Failure]

My fantasy. Who's the one dreaming of trading for Manning and LT?

[Sgt PSN]

I think the overall difference between McNabb and Manning is pretty big, too. I guess that's my point.

I don't think anyone here would dispute the differences between Manning and McNabb.  However, I think it's a different story for runningbacks simply for the fact that if the runningback is good, he will do well just about anywhere and a QB needs to have the offensive system tailored specifically to him. 

Obviously, runningback productivity can increase or decrease based on the system he plays in but I think a good back will still be productive even when he's not playing in a system that is best suited for his particular style of play.