Another target for a PG attack

[ice grillin you]

funny that you would mention three qb's who had weak wr corps

not to mention that each one had exactly one championship game each and they each not only went undefeated in those but also (aghast!!) were somehow able to win a superbowl

[rjs246]

I think you meant "(gasp!!)". Duh.

[henchmanUK]

funny that you would mention three qb's who had weak wr corps

not to mention that each one had exactly one championship game each and they each not only went undefeated in those but also (aghast!!) were somehow able to win a superbowl

Therefore, they are all better than McNabb, right?  BTW, Art Monk and Gary Clark SUCKED.

[T_Section224]

so back to the point of the thread, has PG attacked him yet?

[Wingspan]

I know Freddie ran the wrong route. However, a better WR MAKES THAT PLAY. His hands WERE on that ball.

Point remains the same. Blaming McNabb for that pick is farging retarded.

was freddie the only WR out on a route on that play?

mcnabb makes bad decisions, and the decision to throw there was a bad one. while it may have been a well thrown pass...the decision to throw it there was not good.

[ice grillin you]

Therefore, they are all better than McNabb, right?   BTW, Art Monk and Gary Clark SUCKED.

never said they were better than mcnabb...you must be running out of ammo


btw monk was on the back end of a great career but hardly struck fear into defenses at that point...clark was a good wr who had a great year...overall their wr's were ok...rypien just happened to have an unreal year

I think you meant "(gasp!!)". Duh

pump your brakes homie

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

was freddie the only WR out on a route on that play?

He could have very well been the only one remotely open.

[henchmanUK]

Therefore, they are all better than McNabb, right?   BTW, Art Monk and Gary Clark SUCKED.

never said they were better than mcnabb...you must be running out of ammo


btw monk was on the back end of a great career but hardly struck fear into defenses at that point...clark was a good wr who had a great year...overall their wr's were ok...rypien just happened to have an unreal year

So McNabb IS better than those QBs, even though they all won Super Bowls. You'd think, therefore, that McNabb is capable of winning one, no? Have your opinion on the Skins receivers - I think it's wrong -  but they sure are better that what Donovan's had to work with over the years, TO excepted.

[Wingspan]

was freddie the only WR out on a route on that play?

He could have very well been the only one remotely open.

my point (back a few posts) is that he does not make the best decisions when it comes to crunch time. we all know, and we have all seen it...some chose to deny it.

that being said, i dont want him gone by any means. but he has plenty of weaknesses...too many to be considered great.

[ice grillin you]

He could have very well been the only one remotely open

and if the wr's werent open then the rb's ran the wrong route or were covered or had a heart attack..and if that hadnt happened fraley allowed to much push up the middle...but it didnt matter cause even if he hadnt tra was like a matador on that play...yeah but andy called the wrong play anyway...oh and the stadium people convienantly turned up the air conditioning right before that play and it redirected the ball plus the artifical noise in the dome caused mcnabb not to be able to audible into a play that would have surely been a touchdown

[rjs246]

Preposterous.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

You've completely lost your mind, IGY.  You made very little sense initially and were mildly amusing.


Now, you're completely out of your gord.

[henchmanUK]

He could have very well been the only one remotely open

and if the wr's werent open then the rb's ran the wrong route or were covered or had a heart attack..and if that hadnt happened fraley allowed to much push up the middle...but it didnt matter cause even if he hadnt tra was like a matador on that play...yeah but andy called the wrong play anyway...oh and the stadium people convienantly turned up the air conditioning right before that play and it redirected the ball plus the artifical noise in the dome caused mcnabb not to be able to audible into a play that would have surely been a touchdown

And you accuse ME of running out of ammo?

[rjs246]

Now, you're completely out of your gord.

I think you meant "gourd." Duh.

[ice grillin you]

point is that this thread has contained every excuse in the book as to why mcnabb cant win the big game...but ive yet to hear from anyone why it couldnt be that he just isnt good enough