Is McNabb too sensitive?

[MDS]

you forgetting about killing worms and taking a job away from a white qb (according to the other cf)

[smeags]

-not throwing interceptions

unless in big games.

[shorebird]

Every fantasy ranking I've seen has Kolb rated ahead of McNabb.

[Sgt PSN]

Every fantasy ranking I've seen has Kolb rated ahead of McNabb.

That has pretty much no bearing at all on what the fantasy rankers think of McNabb or Kolb as NFL quarterbacks.  Kolb has Shady, Pimp, Maclin, Celek and Avant.  McNabb has Hot Pants Cooley. 

Unless Kolb turns out to be totally useless, he's going to put up fairly good fantasy numbers.  Hell, once upon a time Culpepper and Bulger were among the top fantasy qb's but it turned out that neither was really competent at their position, they just had exceptional skill players to throw to. 

If McNabb is still an Eagle and Kolb is the starting qb for the Skins, McNabb would be rated well ahead of Kolb. 

[LBIggle]

mine too.  but in my fantasy mcnabb is dying slowly via Reid giving him a Cleveland steamer.

[Seabiscuit36]

http://footballoutsiders.com/walkthrough/2010/walkthrough-mcnabb-deniers

[Don Ho]

Gonzalez mentioned a new third group, one that wants everyone to stop dwelling on McNabb and focus on the present. He called them the MoveOn(fromMcNabb).org contingent

Count me in!

[ice grillin you]

youre crazy....i wanna see the dallas skins game tomorrow almost as much as the eagles packers

this whole year is about what mcnabb does....good or bad

[Don Ho]

You know I'm full of shtein. Of course I'll be watching the skins game with as much interest as the birds game. McNabb, new team, Cowboys, oh yeah.

[MMH]

That FO article is undeniably factual, but still misses the point.  No one in Philly, particularly before 2008, cared about anything but a championship, and reasonably so.  McNabb certainly wasn't the biggest problem preventing that (Reid is hands down);  but he certainly contributed.  And the one argument in there that I disagree with is that McNabb is this dignified luminary.  He's a bitch, and he can't stand above criticism, deserved or otherwise.

And he might very well get killed behind that joke of a line in DC.  But at least Shanny will give him some farging run support, unlike the fatman.

[Don Ho]

Well said.  Fatty was most of the problem.  All DMac needed was one SB win and the guy would have been god.  shtein, if he had lead the birds down field and beat the Cardinals, three playoff wins on the road would have helped cement a positive legacy.  The two final games at Dallas last year helped add fuel to all the negatives. 

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

All McNabb apologists please check in.  Then go farg yourselves.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Caption please:

[SD]

Mommy

[SunMo]

Andy...come back Andy...Andy!....I'm sorry!  I'm sorry Andy!  Come back!