Donovan McNabb

[Sgt PSN]

Just thinking more about this, and I'm curious.

Of the Eagles notable modern QBs, say, Jaworski, Cunningham and McNabb, which one would you take as a franchise QB-- assuming each is in his physical prime.

I'd probably take Randall as long as I didn't have to take his o-line or Buddy with him.  I'll always be curious about how good he might have been with a better o-line and better offensive coaching. 

[Rome]

bullshtein.  they rarely beat the cardinals.

[Sgt PSN]

bullshtein.  they rarely beat the cardinals.

MarTay Jenkins, anyone?

[ice grillin you]

randall won a LEAGUE mvp

donovan won a best qb in the nfc east award over patrick ramsey....quincy carter and kerry collins

[Sgt PSN]

randall won a LEAGUE mvp

donovan won a best qb in the nfc east award over patrick ramsey....quincy carter and kerry collins

lol

[Rome]

McNabb was a Hoyda but no one can argue that he was all-world in 2004.   

[ice grillin you]

if only the superbowl wasnt played in 2005

[Sgt PSN]

McNabb was a Hoyda but no one can argue that he was all-world in 2004.   

He was.  Even when throwing to receivers not named TO, his passes seemed to be more accurate and were hitting guys in stride.  Even after TO got hurt, he still played at a very high level for the last few weeks of the reg season and playoffs.

[ice grillin you]

im pretty sure he didnt play in the regular season after TO went down

[Rome]

You're physically incapable of any sort of measured thought, aren't you?

McNabb was great in 2004.  That is an indisputable fact.  So stop your nonsense.

[Sgt PSN]

im pretty sure he didnt play in the regular season after TO went down

Don't know why, but I was thinking that TO got hurt around week 13, but I just double checked at it was week 15.  McNabb did start the following week against St Louis on MNF (I was there with Chuggie, Thawk and the departed Father Demon, Phanatic and Phillymic), but the 1st team offense played like 1 or 2 series and was pulled.  I'm pretty sure McNabb threw a td to Freddie Mitchell during the few snaps he did take that game.  He did sit out the season finale completely though.

[PhillyPhreak54]

I'd take Randall - especially if he had a coach and an OL.

Randall
McNabb
Jaws

Igy's List

Randall
Jaws
Vick
Brad Goebel
Jeff Kemp
Mike McMahon
Rodney Peete
Ty Detmer
Jim McMahon
Andy Hall
Koy Detmer
AJ Feeley
Casey Weldon
Donovan McNabb

[hbionic]

im pretty sure he didnt play in the regular season after TO went down

Don't know why, but I was thinking that TO got hurt around week 13, but I just double checked at it was week 15.  McNabb did start the following week against St Louis on MNF (I was there with Chuggie, Thawk and the departed Father Demon, Phanatic and Phillymic), but the 1st team offense played like 1 or 2 series and was pulled.  I'm pretty sure McNabb threw a td to Freddie Mitchell during the few snaps he did take that game.  He did sit out the season finale completely though.

Not only that, but I'm pretty sure I shared the bed with the only chick in the trip and obviously nothing happened.

But yeah, McNabb led an easy opening drive for a TD to Freddie as my compatriot stated. We then took over the stadium.

[MDS]

ill take 5 pre-2002 over anyone

once the injury/bucs choke/2003 early season collapse hit he turned into an epic douchebag and it only got worse.

[Zanshin]

All things being equal, I'd have to go: Cunningham, McNabb, Jaws. Vick would be distantly down the list, because for all of the in-his-prime flashy potential, he never sustained success anywhere and he's so feast or famine. The other guys showed they could work within a team with some consistency.