2013 Grade It

[ice grillin you]

Overall Grade= A

Because Kurt Coleman is all but gone. That will make it an enjoyable viewing pleasure, even if we lose every game miserably.

if you are gonna go "we" you at least have to watch the draft

[SD]

Also if you average all igys grades (for arguments sake I assigned a C grade as 75 points...a B grade as 85 points etc. since he didn't specify plus or minus) the grade comes out to a high C average. I did the math in my head but in pretty sure that's correct.

[ice grillin you]

Also if you average all igys grades (for arguments sake I assigned a C grade as 75 points...a B grade as 85 points etc. since he didn't specify plus or minus) the grade comes out to a high C average. I did the math in my head but in pretty sure that's correct.

you have to weight the picks tho....a great 7th round pick doesnt carry the same grade as a great second round pick

[SD]

Which pick did you hate more Logan or Barkley?

[Eagles_Legendz]

bottom line is we can say whatever we want, the wolff's and poyer's of the world are likely going to be depth players and not much more (obviously there's a chance that's wrong  but the majority of the time).  the draft also isn't likely going to be made or broken on whether logan pans out or not.  seems to me with the way it unfolded if lane johnson is franchise tackle the better part of the next decade and barkley becomes an effective starter, the draft will be good, and if those things don't turn out the draft will be bad, unless the 5th-7th round picks all contribute at high levels which is incredibly unlikely.

[ice grillin you]

Which pick did you hate more Logan or Barkley?

i dont hate barkley....i fully admit i have no clue as to how good or bad any qb will be...my disagreement there is that they had much better options

bennie imo is a straight up bad player

[Rome]

Wah.

Solid B to B+.

[PhillyPhreak54]

You seem to be the only person saying his not a good player.

i also happen to be the only person who has ever seen him play

do the mathematics

i have been and could be again massively wrong...time will show this....but imo the guy just isnt a good player

I've seen a ton of LSU games.

[Geowhizzer]

Also if you average all igys grades (for arguments sake I assigned a C grade as 75 points...a B grade as 85 points etc. since he didn't specify plus or minus) the grade comes out to a high C average. I did the math in my head but in pretty sure that's correct.

Ha... I had nearly the same thing go through my head, but a GPA type thing.  With Igy's grades, the Eagles would have a 2.3 GPA - not high C, but in the C ranger nevertheless.

Then I just figured it was the teacher in me and decided to not post it at the time.

[hbionic]

Overall Grade= A

Because Kurt Coleman is all but gone. That will make it an enjoyable viewing pleasure, even if we lose every game miserably.

if you are gonna go "we" you at least have to watch the draft

I watched some of it...but reading you guys is much more fun.

[Rome]

You seem to be the only person saying his not a good player.

i also happen to be the only person who has ever seen him play

do the mathematics

i have been and could be again massively wrong...time will show this....but imo the guy just isnt a good player

I've seen a ton of LSU games.

Unless we see a picture of you actually watching an LSU game we're not going to believe you.

[BigEd76]

J's gonna get his ass beat if he says "geaux"

[Sgt PSN]

I liked the Johnson pick.  Since I don't follow college football very closely, I usually spend the month prior to the draft reading up on the 4 or 5 players who the Eagles are most likely to draft.  It addresses a need.  He's really athletic.  He puts Danny Watkins on the bench.  All around win.  Sure, they probably could have traded back and still gotten one of the other top rated tackles, but it seems like they had Johnson as their top ranked T so I'm not gonna hate on them for picking a guy they more or less coveted.   

Ertz in the 2nd just didn't make sense.  TE isn't really that big of a need on this team so it's a bit of a head scratcher that they'd draft one so high.  Looks like he can be a really nice player but I think the Eagles kind of put the cart in front of the horse a little bit.

I know practically nothing about Bennie Logan other than the fact that he played in the SEC.  And that tells me that he's played against some of the best and biggest offensive lines in the country and had pretty good success against them.  I'm not going to get super excited about this pick and I'm not condemning it either, but if they wanted a DT then the SEC is a good place to look.   

I'd have been all over Barkley last year.  Actually, I was all over Barkley last year.  And it's not that my opinion of him is any different now than it was then, but I thought Barkley would have been a great fit for Reid's offense and I'm not really sure how he fits into Kelly's scheme.  I do think he has the best pro-potential out of all the other QB's in this draft class though.  I guess if Kelly is eyeing him as a potential franchise QB and is going to build an offense to Barkley's strengths, then this could very well be the steal of the draft.  But things rarely work out that way in Philly so I'm not getting my hopes up. 

The rest of the draft picks I know little to nothing about.  Some brief reading of pre-draft reports on them all seem fairly encouraging though. 

B- for now.  If Barkley winds up being the real deal and the Eagles have a QB for 10 years then it's got A++ potential.   

[Don Ho]

Also if you average all igys grades (for arguments sake I assigned a C grade as 75 points...a B grade as 85 points etc. since he didn't specify plus or minus) the grade comes out to a high C average. I did the math in my head but in pretty sure that's correct.

Ha... I had nearly the same thing go through my head, but a GPA type thing.  With Igy's grades, the Eagles would have a 2.3 GPA - not high C, but in the C ranger nevertheless.

Then I just figured it was the teacher in me and decided to not post it at the time.

Sounds like summer school.

[Geowhizzer]

Also if you average all igys grades (for arguments sake I assigned a C grade as 75 points...a B grade as 85 points etc. since he didn't specify plus or minus) the grade comes out to a high C average. I did the math in my head but in pretty sure that's correct.

Ha... I had nearly the same thing go through my head, but a GPA type thing.  With Igy's grades, the Eagles would have a 2.3 GPA - not high C, but in the C ranger nevertheless.

Then I just figured it was the teacher in me and decided to not post it at the time.

Sounds like summer school.

Summer school is a total waste, but that's a different story.