Donovan McNabb

[Zanshin]

I mean at his very best, he was good. But at his worst, he was awful. And that's even taking the passive aggressive personality and choking out of the equation. What he never was: consistently great over his total body of work.

[Zanshin]

And I don't even have an axe to grind. I mean he just doesn't fit the bill.

[ice grillin you]

even having this discussion is giving him to much credit....im not even hyperbolizing....he has ZERO chance to make it....he just doesnt

we all need to stop it

[PhillyPhreak54]

I seen I've worked igy up into a frothy bedwetter diatribe.

[ice grillin you]

you didnt do it

this did....

I don't think there's much doubt that he's going into the HOF.   

[QB Eagles]

Sarge must have meant the Eagles HOF. I think he makes that one.

Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, and Drew Brees are your shoo-in HOF QBs. Eli Manning and Ben Roethlisburger have decent chances due to multiple Super Bowl wins for beloved franchises.

Those are the McNabb draft era (98-04) guys. The first three played for many years like beings from another planet, McNabb never did. The second two are winners, McNabb never was.

McNabb will never be enshrined in the same hall as those guys, and doesn't deserve to be. Hell, Randall has a better claim to the HOF for innovating the position. If there was a Hall of Boomer Esiason and Steve McNair and Phil Simms, that would be the place for McNabb.

[Diomedes]

Sarge must have been drinking.   igy is right.  Zero chance. 

[Rome]

McNabb in the HOF?   This discussion makes the all-time stupid list.  Well done, ladies.

[Sgt PSN]

Sarge must have been drinking.

I actually was, but not enough to claim drunk posting.  I don't know why, I just have this feeling that voters are going to feel sorry for the guy. 

[SD]

Has a player ever gotten into the hof based on sympathy votes? I doubt he becomes the first. He wins the sb in 2004 and his legendary spot in Philly is cemented meaning he would get hof consideration. Still don't know if that would give him enough of a push but its something people would start his hof candidacy resume with.

[Dillen]

This place gets dumber by the farging day.

[MDS]

what is this, the 3rd grade? people are going to feel sorry for donovan and put him in? jesus christ

[ice grillin you]

my sympathy vote would go to dirty waters

rip

[hbionic]

I actually was, but not enough to claim drunk posting.  I don't know why, I just have this feeling that voters are going to feel sorry for the guy.

So he's going to be booed into the Hall of Fame?

[hbionic]

Sarge must have meant Phreak's HOF. I think he makes that one.