This Team Will NOT Win Anything... Ever.

[PhillyPhreak54]

he doesnt suck. no one is saying he sucks. hes just a bitch and a choke artist.

The bellyaching about his accuracy (on perfectly catchable balls) says otherwise. So does the lack of respect he gets in this city.

[ice grillin you]

lol, remember yesterday when Donovan got sacked and was trying to get away and the ref started to blow his whistle for in the grasp, but the tackle was already in progress?  he immediately starts calling for a flag for late hit, lol.  he knew the only way they were going to move the ball was by penalty.  classic stuff.

hes become so shook against the blitz over the last couple seasons....he doesnt even try and make a play now...once he sees it coming he pulls the ball down panicks and looks for a place to hide

[MDS]

he doesnt suck. no one is saying he sucks. hes just a bitch and a choke artist.

The bellyaching about his accuracy (on perfectly catchable balls) says otherwise. So does the lack of respect he gets in this city.

he doesnt get any respect because a. he hasnt won anything b. hes an entitled little bitch and c. he hates us

[Eagles_Legendz]

So says the fans. But analysts and NFL commentators always seem to rank him up there.

ANd if he sucks so much and is terribly inaccurate, why would there be a sizable market for him?

What? What market is there for him? Have the Eagles been bombarded with trade offers for McNabb that I managed to miss over the past 5 years?

I don't think the Eagles have been shopping McNabb in the past.  With the state of QB play elsewhere in the league, McNabb has enough years left as an above average QB that he'd get them something decent in return.

[SunMo]

he doesnt suck. no one is saying he sucks. hes just a bitch and a choke artist.

The bellyaching about his accuracy (on perfectly catchable balls) says otherwise. So does the lack of respect he gets in this city.

you're right, his career 59.0 completion % screams ACCURACY

[PhillyPhreak54]

But he's not good enough to play QB for the Eagles, right?

[MDS]

the eagles have the best roster in football.

[PhillyPhreak54]

he doesnt suck. no one is saying he sucks. hes just a bitch and a choke artist.

The bellyaching about his accuracy (on perfectly catchable balls) says otherwise. So does the lack of respect he gets in this city.

you're right, his career 59.0 completion % screams ACCURACY

I was talking about yesterday.

I know what his career percentage is and know that he is not the best when it comes to completion percentage. But call a spade a spade and not turn every dropped ball (or completed ball, in Todd's case) into how inaccurate he is. That happens every week in the NFL - QBs get the ball out and guys have to make plays on poor throws.

[Munson]

The worst part is any dope here would know enough to offset his inaccuracies by running the ball....and NFL coaches who just got 3 year extensions can't seem to figure that out.

[ice grillin you]

he doesnt suck. no one is saying he sucks. hes just a bitch and a choke artist.

The bellyaching about his accuracy (on perfectly catchable balls) says otherwise. So does the lack of respect he gets in this city.

you're right, his career 59.0 completion % screams ACCURACY

of all active qb's in the nfl right now mcnabb ranks 26th in completion %

not. good.

[Eagles_Legendz]

But he's not good enough to play QB for the Eagles, right?

He's above average--probably somewhere around 10th-12th in the league if I was picking quarterbacks.  When you get 10 years of that, at some point you just need to make a change.  When you add 10 years of the same shtein coupled with the fact he throws everyone under the bus the first chance he gets, yes I'd rather take my chances with someone else.  The Eagles have enough talent on offense for Kolb or whoever to run the offense proficiently.  You get an ok package back for McNabb after the season (2nd + 5th and a conditional 2nd or 3rd is what I imagine they'd get) and I move him.

[PhillyPhreak54]

he doesnt suck. no one is saying he sucks. hes just a bitch and a choke artist.

The bellyaching about his accuracy (on perfectly catchable balls) says otherwise. So does the lack of respect he gets in this city.

you're right, his career 59.0 completion % screams ACCURACY

Dan Marino = 59.4%
Troy Aikman = 61.5%
Terry Bradshaw = 51.9%
Randall = 56.6%
John Elway = 56.9%
Dan Fouts = 58.8%
Jaws = 53.1%
Bernie Kosar = 59.3%
Eli Manning = 57%
Warren Moon = 58.4%
Jim Plunkett = 52.5%
Phil Simms = 55.4%
Roger Staubach = 57%
Bart Starr = 57.4%
Fran Tarkenton = 57%
Joe Theismann = 56.7%
Johnny Unitas = 54.6%
Doug Williams = 49.5%

[Munson]

Elway was only 56.9? damn...

[SunMo]

that's been sitting on a PC clipboard for a rainy day, and it's mother farging pouring right now

[PhillyPhreak54]

lol...negative sir.

I just went to pro-football reference and looked 'em up.