Fat Ass or Dumb Ass

[ice grillin you]

troy brown was better than any eagle wr but he was nothing special...he was 100% a tom brady creation....lol at you even mentioning deion branch...

and however many >'s you used for belichek vs reid times them by ten and replace the names with brady and mcnabb

brady might be the best qb EVER mcnabb might be the best eagle qb ever...just stop talking brady mcnabb...its actually sickening

Don't you know the cool thing to do is diminish the Eagle players and prop up the opposing players?!

who did that

[Munson]

I just like when IGY says there's no way to ever know what Manning or Brady would do in this offense....but somehow he knows what goes on in McNabb's head and how he actually wantsto lose and loses on purpose just cause he's mad at the fans.


One hypothetical situation that actually makes logical sense=UNPOSSIBLE TO KNOW
The other that makes absolutely no sense at all=Definitely possible

[Munson]

troy brown was better than any eagle wr but he was nothing special...he was 100% a tom brady creation....lol at you even mentioning deion branch...

and however many >'s you used for belichek vs reid times them by ten and replace the names with brady and mcnabb

brady might be the best qb EVER mcnabb might be the best eagle qb ever...just stop talking brady mcnabb...its actually sickening

Don't you know the cool thing to do is diminish the Eagle players and prop up the opposing players?!

who did that

Christ you're an idiot.

Deion Branch was an actual NFL player and has proven that by continuing to play in the NFL. Pinkston fell off the face of the Earth and Thrash went back to Washington...which is the same thing.

Brady wouldn't have won a damn thing in Philly. McNabb would have still gotten the Pats a ring with that team, gameplan, and vastly superior coach.

Shut up.

[Sgt PSN]

Brady wouldn't have won a damn thing in Philly. McNabb would have still gotten the Pats a ring with that team, gameplan, and vastly superior coach.

i can't agree or disagree with absolute certainty either way.  mcnabb's inaccuracy could very well have cost the pats a championship or 2.  it could be argued that since the pats didn't have elite wr's, they relied on accuracy and proper touch on the ball in order to make plays.  because aside from accuracy issues, another issue of mcnabb's has been the heat he throws on the short/intermediate routes that could go through a brick wall. 

the truth is, the reason the pats won a few titles is because they had complete teams with no glaring weaknesses at all and during the eagles best years they had problems at wr, fb, lb and head coach.

[ice grillin you]

deion branch sucks and at best was as good a wr as thrash...and if you wanna go who was better in their respective primes thrash was marginally better...the point is the difference in them is negligible and to try and say brady won because he had wr's and mcnabb didnt is assinine...but again youd have to actually watch the games and know what you were looking at when this all happened and you were like 12 when this all went down

I just like when IGY says there's no way to ever know what Manning or Brady would do in this offense....but somehow he knows what goes on in McNabb's head and how he actually wantsto lose and loses on purpose just cause he's mad at the fans.


One hypothetical situation that actually makes logical sense=UNPOSSIBLE TO KNOW
The other that makes absolutely no sense at all=Definitely possible

newsflash: brady NEVER PLAYED WITH THE EAGLES...while donovan has played in the nfl for the last 11 seasons...whether you agree that donovan has serious emotional issues and has a pathological woe is me attitude the fact is ive been able to watch him on the field for over a decade and make that determination...how are you comparing that to something thats never even farging happened...are you that stupid??

[Munson]

Brady wouldn't have won a damn thing in Philly. McNabb would have still gotten the Pats a ring with that team, gameplan, and vastly superior coach.

i can't agree or disagree with absolute certainty either way.  mcnabb's inaccuracy could very well have cost the pats a championship or 2.  it could be argued that since the pats didn't have elite wr's, they relied on accuracy and proper touch on the ball in order to make plays.  because aside from accuracy issues, another issue of mcnabb's has been the heat he throws on the short/intermediate routes that could go through a brick wall. 

the truth is, the reason the pats won a few titles is because they had complete teams with no glaring weaknesses at all and during the eagles best years they had problems at wr, fb and/or lb. 

I agree, but if McNabbs limited accuracy could get to the NFC Championship game with the WR's he had here....I don't think it's a far stretch to say he could win a SB with better WR's, a better game plan, and a coach who would know how to call a game/put McNabb in a better position to win.

[Munson]

deion branch sucks and at best was as good a wr as thrash...and if you wanna go who was better in their respective primes thrash was marginally better...the point is the difference in them is negligible and to try and say brady won because he had wr's and mcnabb didnt is assinine...but again youd have to actually watch the games and know what you were looking at when this all happened and you were like 12 when this all went down

I just like when IGY says there's no way to ever know what Manning or Brady would do in this offense....but somehow he knows what goes on in McNabb's head and how he actually wantsto lose and loses on purpose just cause he's mad at the fans.


One hypothetical situation that actually makes logical sense=UNPOSSIBLE TO KNOW
The other that makes absolutely no sense at all=Definitely possible

newsflash: brady NEVER PLAYED WITH THE EAGLES...while donovan has played in the nfl for the last 11 seasons...whether you agree that donovan has serious emotional issues and has a pathological woe is me attitude the fact is ive been able to watch him on the field for over a decade and make that determination...how are you comparing that to something thats never even farging happened...are you that stupid??

RIF

1. I never said he won strictly because of better WR's. RIF

2. LOL yes, you know everything about the guys brain because you've watched him play football and win more games then he lost...but no obviously he was trying to lose those games because he's mad at the Dirty 30.


You are a joke. I don't even have to say anything else because the more you try and play Dr. Phil to a guy you've never met in your life, the more of an ass you make out of yourself.

[ice grillin you]

the nfc has sucked ass for basically mcnabbs whole career...thats the only reason he had the "success" he did and still could only even get to one superbowl...look at his record against the afc...hes not even guaranteed to make the playoffs in the afc much less win a superbowl in that conference...i give mcnabb credit for being the best qb in a terrible division and taking advantage but christ tom brady who might be the best ever missed the playoffs twice over there


again this is too unimaginable to even process...comparing brady to mcnabb...whats next a duce staley jim brown showdown

[rjs246]

I'm pretty sure that my post already settled this discussion so you can all feel free to shut up now.

[Munson]

the nfc has sucked ass for basically mcnabbs whole career...thats the only reason he had the "success" he did and still could only even get to one superbowl...look at his record against the afc...hes not even guaranteed to make the playoffs in the afc much less win a superbowl in that conference...i give mcnabb credit for being the best qb in a terrible division and taking advantage but christ tom brady who might be the best ever missed the playoffs twice over there


again this is too unimaginable to even process...comparing brady to mcnabb...whats next a duce staley jim brown showdown

Yes, Only McNabb has that record against the AFC. It has nothing to do with the rest of the team or the terrible coach.

You've done a good job over the years of blaming the QB too much and never giving him the credit when they win. The pendulum swings both ways...if he has that much influence on the team when they lose, he has that same influence when they win.



Lol at you thinking Tom Brady is successful in Andy Reid's offense throwing to James Thrash and Todd Pinkston. And Freddie Mitchell. And Na Brown.

[Sgt PSN]

whats next a duce staley jim brown showdown

like anyone can even compare the 2 of them.  it's gotta be duce, right?

[Munson]

Jim Brown didn't have a cool "duuuuuuce" like chant. Duce obviously has the advantage.

[MDS]

Lol @ giving credit to mcnabb.

Wins over the packers in november don't count. His one two three four five playoff failures say hi. He failed miserably in everyone of those games and has a zesty attitude to go along with it.

He may win elsewhere if its the right spot. He's the besr qb in birds historÝ. But its beyond time to move on. Reid too.

[Munson]

The question is who should we get rid of first....by and far it's Reid. He's never going to become a balanced coach and therefore will never be a winner.

McNabb has overcome zesty playcalling, coaching, and supporting casts for most of his career. I'd rather stick with him than Reid.

[smeags]

deion branch sucks and at best was as good a wr as thrash...and if you wanna go who was better in their respective primes thrash was marginally better...the point is the difference in them is negligible

ummm, no. it was a bit more than negligible. quite a bit  more considering branch has played like 4-5 less seasons.

thrash - 290catches / 3646yrds - 12.6avg - 22tds

branch - 363 catches / 4697yrds - 12.9avg - 27tds


disclaimer - i am not defending mcnabb here - just merely picking apart this silly post of yours.