Donovan McNabb

[ice grillin you]

except that someone else is kevin kolb and that is in no way reasonable

give me a legit mcnabb replacement and im on board with getting him out but ive yet to hear one

[SunMo]

Jeff George

[rjs246]

except that someone else is kevin kolb and that is in no way reasonable

give me a legit mcnabb replacement and im on board with getting him out but ive yet to hear one

Sure you're completely right about that. But I hate that nonsense.

"Andy Reid is terrible."
"Yeah but he shouldn't lose his job because who would replace him?"

"McNabb is a big game choke artist who has the thin skin of a 12 year old girl."
"Yeah but who is any better? Got to keep him."

Both arguments make sense, but it's bullshtein. Putting up with mediocrity just because we don't know if there's something better out there farging sucks.

[Tomahawk]

McNabb can't have the thin skin of a 12 year old girl. Stephen A. Smith said his skin is alligator thick. You should read the whole article before posting nonsense

[stalker]

The argument for McNabb is completely valid. Name 6 quarterbacks whether available or not that would be better here than McNabb.

[rjs246]

I can name two on the Patriots' roster alone. Oh snap!

And why is it valid for McNabb but not Reid? There's no guarantee that any coach will do better just like there's no guarantee that any QB would do better.

[ice grillin you]

except that someone else is kevin kolb and that is in no way reasonable

give me a legit mcnabb replacement and im on board with getting him out but ive yet to hear one

Sure you're completely right about that. But I hate that nonsense.

"Andy Reid is terrible."
"Yeah but he shouldn't lose his job because who would replace him?"

"McNabb is a big game choke artist who has the thin skin of a 12 year old girl."
"Yeah but who is any better? Got to keep him."

Both arguments make sense, but it's bullshtein. Putting up with mediocrity just because we don't know if there's something better out there farging sucks.

its 1000 times easier to replace a coach than a qb

qb's as good as mcnabb dont come along often and if you wanna replace them you damn well better have a good plan for doing so

[Tomahawk]

Coaching is easier than actually playing

Also, you gotta be kidding about Cassel.

[rjs246]

Fine. Wanting something more from the QB position is still a valid position to take. And McNabb is still a whiny cracker ass cracker.

[stalker]

I can name two on the Patriots' roster alone. Oh snap!

And why is it valid for McNabb but not Reid? There's no guarantee that any coach will do better just like there's no guarantee that any QB would do better.

So, you would dump McNabb for a career backup who didn't make the playoffs in the weak AFC or a gimp who may or may not play again. Brady's fate is not set in stone by any means. Those post-op infections can last dormant a long time. For all we know, he may be a peg leg next year.

The list I can come up with:

1. Peyton Manning
2. Drew Brees
3. That's it.

[ice grillin you]

i cant stomach the guy either...but i care about the eagles more than i dislike mcnabb...which is why i said gimme a valid replacement plan and im all IN

[rjs246]

Cassel went 11-5 this year. I don't actually think that he's a better QB right now than McNabb. But he's a thousand years younger and didn't exactly stink up the joint in his first chance to show what he can do...

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Cassel = Matt Schaub

[Magical_Retard]

Cassel playing with these WRs and not Moss and Welker would have been hilariously bad. Oh yeah and no running game.

[stalker]

Agreed on Cassell, I believe he has a nice upside but we want to win now!

His victories were:

KC
Jets
SF
Denver
Rams
Bills
**Miami**
Seattle
Oakland
**Cards**
Buffalo

So, they beat 2 playoff caliber teams (if you want to call Arizona playoff caliber). I am not terribly impressed.

He threw 21 TD's and 11 int's an okay ratio, nothing that jumps out. Put Randy Moss in our offense and McNabb throws 40 TD's.