McNabb, Feeley, or Kolb

[Magical_Retard]

i thought mcnabb was making strides without TO last season till the last 2 games. some of those offensive performances were without stallworth in the lineup. our starting WRs were baskett and brown.

just think about that for a second. hell remember they were going into the season perfectly content with having baskett and brown be the starters. 1 non drafted rookie and the other a 2 yr player. 2 yrs removed from the Superbowl and instead of trying to acquire top talent to get back to the superbowl Reid was content with brown and baskett.

[ice grillin you]

I dunno...I think his historical ball-delivery issues have always prevented him from being a good WCO fit.

If one was in a generous mood, perhaps one could attribute his "accuracy" issues to a (justifiable) lack of confidence in his receivers, (with his solution to either hold the ball too long or throw worm burners thus avoiding the int.,) but even as I type this it seems a bit of a stretch.

Without rare, physical receivers like Owens who will "go get" errant balls, the WCO system demands consistent accuracy and "touch" and I don't think he ever qualified in this area.

i think youre revising history a little bit...mcnabb was super accurate in 04 and TO was catching balls in perfect stride not going to get them....mcnabbs accuracy problems (and yes he has them) were hidden because TO could get open whenever he wanted so there were far less needles that had to be threaded both to TO and the field that he opened up to others...

why reid wasnt able to see this before TO and why he refused to not adequetely replace TO is up for debate

[reese125]

2 yrs removed from the Superbowl and instead of trying to acquire top talent to get back to the superbowl Reid was content with brown and baskett.

..which is disgusting. We as fans are severely brainwashed and have been for a while in believing McNabb can run the WCO effectively. When you run around in the pocket, it obviously builds extra time for the receivers to get open. Sure he has the occasional "wow" passes that are timed perfectly, but lets not lose fact that the majority of the passes to his receivers are potluck. They are either standing there waiting for the pass or diving down to get it . You rarely see any YAC's for that very reason. Funny how we saw those YACs with AJ or Garcia, and they would of been 5 x's better with above avg receivers

[pinoyboy2pt0]

It's quite the retarded situation if you think about it.

Summed up, Reid won't adapt his system for a QB that doesn't fit it.  ...and he hand picked McNabb.  Story of the Reid era. 

[Magical_Retard]

2 yrs removed from the Superbowl and instead of trying to acquire top talent to get back to the superbowl Reid was content with brown and baskett.

..which is disgusting. We as fans are severely brainwashed and have been for a while in believing McNabb can run the WCO effectively. When you run around in the pocket, it obviously builds extra time for the receivers to get open. Sure he has the occasional "wow" passes that are timed perfectly, but lets not lose fact that the majority of the passes to his receivers are potluck. They are either standing there waiting for the pass or diving down to get it . You rarely see any YAC's for that very reason. Funny how we saw those YACs with AJ or Garcia, and they would of been 5 x's better with above avg receivers

who has been brainwashed here? ever since i have been on this board (i think since reids 2nd yr) i have heard about mcnabb's inability to be accurate.

im actually glad that majority of the ppl here actually know football and are not like the eagles board knee jerk fans who i had to deal with till i found this place.

[Phillyiggles_fan]

who has been brainwashed here? ever since i have been on this board (i think since reids 2nd yr) i have heard about mcnabb's inability to be accurate.

im actually glad that majority of the ppl here actually know football and are not like the eagles board knee jerk fans who i had to deal with till i found this place.

I think this year McNsbb has shown a considerable drop-off in his ability to evade the rush, and he has actually been caught up to and pulled down from behind this year on more than a few occassions.  This in combination with the fact that his accuracy comes and goes from game to game have really got me down on him this year. 

Many of my friends said at the end of last year that they should've dealt McNabb and kept Garcia.  I thought they were nuts last year, but I don't think that anymore.

[Diomedes]

please consult with vigy for lessons on how to quote properly.  kisses, thanks.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

lightbulb-head Clayton tells us nothing new

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Feeley, apparently, is what we thought he was.

[MDS]

Fire Andy Reid.

[JackStraw]

farg McNabbs injury. Start him until we are officially done to get whatever trade value we can get. Too bad we'll get nothing for Feeley. Get ready for Kolb in a couple weeks.

Goodbye Kearse, Howard, Smith, and the list goes on. This slide from the superbowl has been just the farging worst piece of steaming dog shtein I have seen a team go through since the slide after the summer Jerome died.

Lurie>Bramer>Tose but so farging what.

Linc>Vet>Franklin Field but so farging what.

McNabb>Cunningham>Jaworski but so farging what.

I'f I'm Westbrook I'm taking a steaming twisty twirly "Davenport" in Feeleys locker right about now.

[The BIGSTUD]

Westbrook should take a plump one on Reid's desk. Reid called the plays. If Reid runs, Feeley passes less, which means less INTs.

[JackStraw]

Feeley sent love letters with his eyes on every one of those farging picks. He deserves the corn-adding-for-texture gift.

[Magical_Retard]

Westbrook should take a plump one on Reid's desk. Reid called the plays. If Reid runs, Feeley passes less, which means less INTs.

i saw marty calling the plays.

it doesnt matter though because all of them are idiots of the same.

[rjs246]

I've never seen a QB consistently decide to throw into double coverage as much as I saw Feeley do it tonight. It was almost as though he was doing it intentionally.