HOF finalists announced

[ice grillin you]

randall!!!!!!!!

http://www.profootballhof.com/history/story.jsp?story_id=2235

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

randall!!!!

http://www.profootballhof.com/history/story.jsp?story_id=2235

Eric Allen is probably more deserving.

[Father Demon]

randall!!!!

http://www.profootballhof.com/history/story.jsp?story_id=2235

Also other Eagles:

Eric Allen
Harold Carmichael
Mark Bavaro
Richard Dent
Art monk
Dick Vermeil
Herschel Walker
Ricky Waters

[QB Eagles]

Bruce Matthews should make it on the first try. I think Thurman Thomas and Andre Reed should make it, no questions asked. Beyond that, Michael Irvin and Derrick Thomas probably have a better chance than any of the non-Matthews first year candidates.

Terrell Davis and Randall should both spark some heated arguments within the selection committee (each is a unique case), but I think they will both fall well short.

[ice grillin you]

dont you ever again call art monk an eagle....shame on you when you step thru...old dirty bastich...brooklyn zoo!

[PhillyPhreak54]

I hope Art Monk makes it this year. It'd be nice to hear those Extremers whine for another year, but Monk deserves it.

I also believe Cunningham should go in. But that is very debatable. But Eric Allen definitley deserves to go.

Jerry Jones is on that list.

[Father Demon]

The thing witrh Cunningham is that one could argue he revolutionized the QB position.  Without the likes of him, players like McNabb and Vick may not have made the NFL.

One could argue....

[Father Demon]

dont you ever again call art monk an eagle....shame on you when you step thru...old dirty bastich...brooklyn zoo!

settle down, Francis.

[QB Eagles]

I hope Art Monk makes it this year. It'd be nice to hear those Extremers whine for another year, but Monk deserves it.

Let's not have that argument again. 

[PhillyPhreak54]

We argued about Monk? I don't recall.

[SunMo]

Art Monk is as much an Eagle as Mark Bavaro...step off son

[Diomedes]

What's to argue about?  He should be IN.

[QB Eagles]

I think Thurman Thomas and Andre Reed should make it, no questions asked.

For the record, I think Thomas is a lock for this year. Reed will probably have to wait a while, but in my mind he's the best eligiable WR not in the HOF, certainly better than any all-time taterskins receiver not named Bobby or Charley.

[ice grillin you]

Art Monk is as much an Eagle as Mark Bavaro...step off son


you missed the point dunny

hes also a lot more a taterskin...truth be told that whole list was pretty much an abomination...but i dont want any skins confused with being an eagle


and art monk should need a ticket to get in the hall of fame...he had two (three max) great years and then a whole bunch of good to lackluster years....eff longevity i want greatness in the hall

[Feva]

I'd absolutely LOVE it if Randall made it in.  For some reason though, I just can't see it.  Not on his 1st try anyway.  Eric Allen has a better shot, IMO.. and I'm not even sure his chances are all that great.