Who would you take?

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

MAYBE Larry Johnson eventually

Your PSU homerism is showing.

[Whada_F]

Is Pat Ryan still available?

[Diomedes]

Brady and Brady only.

[rjs246]

MAYBE Larry Johnson eventually

Your PSU homerism is showing.

I would give LJ a 30% chance of breaking 2000 yards this season. Which is about three times higher than I would give any other RB. It has more to do with the team than with him, but still. The dude could do it behind that line and you know that if Herm Edwards could get almost 1700 yards out of an aging Curtis Martin, he'll have no fear of running LJ into the ground.

Is he as good as the other RBs listed? I don't think so, but he's in the perfect situation to lead the league in yardage next year.

[JTrotter Fan]

None...not a single player.  I don't care what Brady did in the past.  I don't care about Manning.  Donovan has flair and he is a helluva good guy.  Screw pretty boy Tom. 

Donovan is my one and only!

[rjs246]

I would trade all of you and most of the people I know for Tom Brady.

[stalker]

I would trade all of you and most of the people I know for Tom Brady.

Even me?

[FreakisaKearseWord]

People. People. Don't want to defy the lord, but McNabb really isn't that good.....2004 was the only year he had atleast a 90 QB average. This is probably because we had a top-tier receiver like TO. If you don't look at 2004, he's only been good-great, not excellent.

[SD_Eagle5]

People. People. Don't want to defy the lord, but McNabb really isn't that good.....2004 was the only year he had atleast a 90 QB average. This is probably because we had a top-tier receiver like TO. If you don't look at 2004, he's only been good-great, not excellent.

I completely disagree, throughout his entire career he's had the lousiest receivers in the league (2004 was the exception) and has never really had a great ground game to take some pressure off him. Name me one QB who's done more with less.

[rjs246]

Tom Brady.

[Phanatic]

People. People. Don't want to defy the lord, but McNabb really isn't that good.....2004 was the only year he had atleast a 90 QB average. This is probably because we had a top-tier receiver like TO. If you don't look at 2004, he's only been good-great, not excellent.

I completely disagree, throughout his entire career he's had the lousiest receivers in the league (2004 was the exception) and has never really had a great ground game to take some pressure off him. Name me one QB who's done more with less.

...and he'll have to keep doing more with less too...

[FreakisaKearseWord]

People. People. Don't want to defy the lord, but McNabb really isn't that good.....2004 was the only year he had atleast a 90 QB average. This is probably because we had a top-tier receiver like TO. If you don't look at 2004, he's only been good-great, not excellent.

I completely disagree, throughout his entire career he's had the lousiest receivers in the league (2004 was the exception) and has never really had a great ground game to take some pressure off him. Name me one QB who's done more with less.

Brady. Branch and Givens were good, but they're nowhere near to TO.

[Munson]

We're not counting the year with TO. Minus 2004, McNabb has thrown to...

CHarles Johnson and Torrence Small
James Thrash and Todd Pinkston, and Na Brown
Same three
Same two and Freddie
and then Reggie Brown and Greg Lewis.


I'm a Pinkston supporter, and I think Reggie is and will be a good #1 in the future....but none of those combinations are close to Deion Branch/David Givens, not to mention Troy Brown before he started to lose it, and David Patten, and Bethel Johnson.

And Brady had a pretty good running game, minus the one year. And I think that was the year they missed the playoffs.

[Feva]

People. People. Don't want to defy the lord, but McNabb really isn't that good.....2004 was the only year he had atleast a 90 QB average. This is probably because we had a top-tier receiver like TO. If you don't look at 2004, he's only been good-great, not excellent.

I completely disagree, throughout his entire career he's had the lousiest receivers in the league (2004 was the exception) and has never really had a great ground game to take some pressure off him. Name me one QB who's done more with less.

Brady. Branch and Givens were good, but they're nowhere near to TO.

Brady has had a much better supporting cast than McNabb... Branch, Givens and Patton (not to mention Dillion) dwarf any receivers McNabb has had to work with not named T.O.

[rjs246]

Feva, Brady won two superbowls with Antwain Smith as his running back. The first SB was won with Troy Brown as their best receiver. Their defense had ONE star in Ty Law (unless you count Lawyer Milloy or Bruschi, but Bruschi wasn't the player then that he is now). That team sucked and Tom Brady was the only reason they won. don't tell me he had a good supporting cast. He had shtein.