McNabb on NFL Network, NFL Live, SportsCenter, etc.

ice grillin you · February 03, 2006, 12:44:35 PM

in case you didnt notice he was on a good team made the superbowl and he choked like a dog...not to mention hes been on numerous good teams and failed to even make the superbowl

there are players in sports whether it be a goalie on a hockey team or a point guard on a basketball team where you will question whether that team can win it all with said player...you all act like its a foreign concept or something...this has been going on since the beginning of time

its not as if i am saying he cant win one...im saying i have major doubts

Feva · February 03, 2006, 01:15:04 PM

Quote from: ice grillin you on February 03, 2006, 12:44:35 PM
in case you didnt notice he was on a good team made the superbowl and he choked like a dog...not to mention hes been on numerous good teams and failed to even make the superbowl

In case YOU didn't notice, in that same Super Bowl, his defense let the Pats score on 4 out of 5 posessions beginning in the 2nd quarter. Did they choke too? Or are you just dumping on the QB because he's the most visible? I don't hear you questioning if Dawkins or Trotter has what it takes to win it all.

PhillyGirl · February 03, 2006, 01:17:52 PM

Yes, McNabb was the sole reason why they lost that Super Bowl.

Cripes, you're embarrassing.

Mad-Lad · February 03, 2006, 01:20:59 PM

I blame Korver.

rjs246 · February 03, 2006, 01:22:35 PM

Reid and Jim Johnson lost the superbowl. They were out-coached to an embarrassing degree. The fact that the Eagles kept it close on the scoreboard is a testament to a very talented roster.

ice grillin you · February 03, 2006, 01:22:50 PM

im dumping on the qb cause hes stunk in every championship game hes ever played

but i know its the defense or the wr's or they werent supposed to win or it was to cold...at what point to you question the qb

I don't hear you questioning if Dawkins or Trotter has what it takes to win it all.

because i dont believe they are the difference btwn winning a title and not winning a title...mcnabb and his turnovers/brain dead play in the nfc champs /superbowl was

the defense didnt come up short in any of the championship games liek the offense...if in all those nfc champs and superbowl had the defense been torched the way the offense was owned then you gotta look at jj and the leaders over there...but it wasnt....so instead i will focus in on the qb and head coach

mussa · February 03, 2006, 01:24:10 PM

IGY you are a supreme douche at times.

SunMo · February 03, 2006, 01:24:59 PM

he didn't stink against Atlanta, he threw one dumb pass that was dropped by Scott, other than that, he played fine.

Wingspan · February 03, 2006, 01:25:13 PM

Quote from: ice grillin you on February 03, 2006, 01:22:50 PM
im dumping on the qb cause hes stunk in every championship game hes ever played

but i know its the defense or the wr's or they werent supposed to win or it was to cold...at what point to you question the qb

I don't hear you questioning if Dawkins or Trotter has what it takes to win it all.

because i dont believe they are the difference btwn winning a title and not winning a title...mcnabb and his turnovers/brain dead play in the superbowl was

the defense didnt come up short in any of the championship games liek the offense...if in all those nfc champs and superbowl had the defense been torched the way the offense was owned then you gotta look at jj and the leaders over there...but it wasnt....so instead i will focus in on the qb and head coach

what the hell were you watching?

so whose fault was it when jurevisious (who runs a 8.45 40) ran for 70 yards? and who gave up points on 4 of 5 possesions in the SB.

oh...yeah thats right mcnabb. he played like dump vs the Rams, and the Falcons....

Feva · February 03, 2006, 01:39:18 PM

Quote from: ice grillin you on February 03, 2006, 01:22:50 PM
im dumping on the qb cause hes stunk in every championship game hes ever played

but i know its the defense or the wr's or they werent supposed to win or it was to cold...at what point to you question the qb

You question the QB when he has all his tools available and still can't get it done... ala Peyton this year. I mean, come championship time, offensively... he's routinely gone against the best teams in the NFL with basically crap around him. You can only carry them so far before the lack of playmakers around you starts to hurt. It's been Pinky & Thrash for most of the run... he's had to deal with no Westbrook next and then no TO last year and still by en large.. got it done.

QuoteI don't hear you questioning if Dawkins or Trotter has what it takes to win it all.

because i dont believe they are the difference btwn winning a title and not winning a title...mcnabb and his turnovers/brain dead play in the nfc champs /superbowl was

the defense didnt come up short in any of the championship games liek the offense...if in all those nfc champs and superbowl had the defense been torched the way the offense was owned then you gotta look at jj and the leaders over there...but it wasnt....so instead i will focus in on the qb and head coach

They're not the difference between winning and losing?! The '00 Ravens and the '02 Bucs would like to have a word with you. Not to mention the one guy who said some crap about defense winning championships. I guess according to you though, we shouldn't even field a defense. Bottom line... had the defense made 1 of those stops in the SB... (Lito's boneheaded play in the end zone, Sheldon picking off that ball that went through his hands and into Branch's, Kearse not getting shook out of his jock by Vrabel) the Eagles could be SB champions.

There's blame to go all around for the championship losses... but you seem hell bent on putting it all on McNabb, while giving everyone else a free pass.

ice grillin you · February 03, 2006, 01:46:22 PM

you cant credit mcnabb with getting to all these championship games and then blame the fact that he had no supporting cast...it doesnt work that way

Bottom line... had the defense made 1 of those stops in the SB... (Lito's boneheaded play in the end zone, Sheldon picking off that ball that went through his hands and into Branch's, Kearse not getting shook out of his jock by Vrabel) the Eagles could be SB champions

wrong...if mcnabb doesnt throw one of those first half interceptions the eagles win...he even threw another one in the end zone but a bogus penalty erased it

enough with arguing minutia and semantics....mcnabb is your man no questions asked...sorry if im not fully on board

Feva · February 03, 2006, 01:58:11 PM

Quote from: ice grillin you on February 03, 2006, 01:46:22 PM
wrong...if mcnabb doesnt throw one of those first half interceptions the eagles win...he even threw another one in the end zone but a bogus penalty erased it

It's not wrong. All of those things with the defense factored into losing the SB just like McNabb's interceptions. The difference between us seems to be that I realize that it takes the team to win or lose the championships, not just 1 player.

MURP · February 03, 2006, 01:59:01 PM

yeah IGY.. You would get rid of Reid, then get rid of McNabb, then do the draft yourself and take care of free agency in your free time... all leading the Eagles to a Superbowl win. We know, we know.

ice grillin you · February 03, 2006, 01:59:46 PM

minus the turnovers the eagle defense was better than the patriots

PhillyGirl · February 03, 2006, 02:02:03 PM

Quote from: ice grillin you on February 03, 2006, 01:59:46 PM
minus the turnovers the eagle defense was better than the patriots

Right, because the Patriots defense had to have stunk....or else McNabb wouldn't have thrown for 345 yards.